Over-healing should not generate extra threat

[Decrith]

The drawback of this "no extra threat from overhealing" is it will encourage a less responsible type of playstyle, this will cause healers to spam healing without thinking of the consequences. Besides, WHMs have shrouds to reduce threat and SCH doesn't even generate enough to be a problem (seriously I've tried to steal aggro from a tank with a SCH, it's really hard)

[Dale]

The drawback of this "no extra threat from overhealing" is it will encourage a less responsible type of playstyle, this will cause healers to spam healing without thinking of the consequences. Besides, WHMs have shrouds to reduce threat and SCH doesn't even generate enough to be a problem (seriously I've tried to steal aggro from a tank with a SCH, it's really hard)

Spamming heals is a waste of MP. That alone is plenty of consequence.

But healers shouldn't be scared to use their heals either because their tank may take off to grab another pull while all of their HoTs are up and those massive 0 hp cures are creating all kinds of threat. It's just silly, and defies common sense. I've never played a game where healing someone for 0 creates lots of threat.

[KraggyKor]

I've never played a game where healing someone for 0 creates lots of threat.

Rift - Justicar soul