The weapons look cool, but (for me) they don't have the relic feeling. I'm going with crafted; regarding Gerlolt, he'll probably give you a quest to expand your crafting log to higher level recipies or something of that sort. Not saying he won't be involved in the upgrade to the Zeniths, as he probably will, just that these weapons might be something else (think the green ilvl70 weapons that needed tome mats., but ilvl90ish.)