Why is Crafting still in the game?

[Tetsaru]

Personally, I felt that PvP gears could be a turn around for crafters but it doesn't seem to be the case.

If SE had made all PvP gears, (i55, i70 and i90) obtainable through crafting, then I think it would have made the crafting scene more lively again.

i55 gears could be made through current mats, then players wear them and get into PvP, earn wolfmarks where these wolfmarks can buy new crafting mats specifically used to craft i70 and i90 gears.

Personally, I think it's messed up that there are ilvl's involved in PVP gear in the first place. Imo, players in PVP matches should be on as even a level as possible in terms of stats; actual skill itself should determine the victor, not "LOL I have biggar numberz than you."

the main idea from crafting/gathering classes is make gil

they are not supposed to give you advantage on endgame contents

You don't think it would be cool to be considered a legendary crafter in the game? To be able to make gear so unique and customized that few can match, to forge blades and armor using secret kobold smelting methods, or weave robes in the technique of the sylphs, and then have them go toe to toe with the best dungeon gear in the game? To have people wanting items with your name on it? Or even something as simple as making your own house the coolest-looking one on your ward? Personally, I'd love to be able to do stuff like that; it'd be a lot more fun than spamming Coil and CT and primals all week...

[Sotek]

You don't think it would be cool to be considered a legendary crafter in the game?

No. Because, while that's a nice concept, it doesn't work in a MMO.

"Oh look, there's Sotek! The Legendary Crafter #15236211".

A much better concept is one they've already played with; having a NPC be a legendary crafter. The Relic quest involves crafters, we need more content like that. More content like XIs Cursed and Salvage gear, where we bring crafted items to a NPC who makes the legendary gear. Content that involves getting the best gear through endgame activities and involving crafters.

[SendohJin]

No. Because, while that's a nice concept, it doesn't work in a MMO.

"Oh look, there's Sotek! The Legendary Crafter #15236211".

A much better concept is one they've already played with; having a NPC be a legendary crafter. The Relic quest involves crafters, we need more content like that. More content like XIs Cursed and Salvage gear, where we bring crafted items to a NPC who makes the legendary gear. Content that involves getting the best gear through endgame activities and involving crafters.

i don't disagree but it doesn't stop them making you "the hero" in the main story.

all they have to do to involve crafters without losing the value of raids is make raids drop EX materia instead of gear, that you need high level crafters to Meld before they are actually useful.

[XiaoliVorgan]

i don't disagree but it doesn't stop them making you "the hero" in the main story.

all they have to do to involve crafters without losing the value of raids is make raids drop EX materia instead of gear, that you need high level crafters to Meld before they are actually useful.

As "a hero" I'm dissapointed that in all the cutscenes, I'm standing off to the side, not saying or doing anything other than nodding my head. Some hero I am.

[Sotek]

i don't disagree but it doesn't stop them making you "the hero" in the main story.

Are we not already the hero in the story? I recall saving every guild from <insert disaster> and becoming better than the best guild masters.

One thing I absolutely do loath though, is when the main scenario sends you to the crafting guild masters, and they don't acknowledge you in the slightest... Would be great if, provided you've completed that guilds questline, the guild master instead sends you off to make whatever yourself, because you can. Extra (and optional) legwork for people with crafts leveled, but it would add a lot to the game in my opinion.