Of course there is more than one solution to the problem, that was exactly what I was pointing out. However, most people refuse to accept that some solutions are better than others. Majority of the people on our server got their wins, and still do, by solely stacking ranged DPS, in which case MT tanking one sister with garuda is indeed the safest way to do the fight assuming the tanks are overgeared to take the double punishment. I was talking from the perspective of melee DPS in the fight since it came up.

My point is: don't use "ranged only" strategy with melees when there are better alternatives and that bringing melees to the fight is just as safe as bringing ranged DPS, it just requires tanks to pull one mob less. If that's a problem for anyone even slightly experienced in the fight, they are either on a power trip, bad players, or lying about being experienced.