A guildie of mine asked me to meld material 4 into his 1lvl70 rose jewelry. I am a lvl 50 GSM with ilvl53. When I attempted to meld the material I got a message saying that the item level was too low so we tried again with the materia 3 he had on hand. Once again we got the same message. We tried this for each rose jewelry item he has, all with the same results.