I think the changes you have added would take away from "Kick back and Fish" style that FSHing currently embodies. As a player that hit 50 FSHing before I got 50 WAR I can tell you that the FSHing mechanic is perfect for what FSHing actually provides.A small steady income off from 5 different fish. If the mechanic was any more time consuming then it currently is we will make like 10 gill and hour. I like the 1 button "oh snap I got something" simpleness that FSHing offers is not like anything else in the game. The fishing holes in Eorzea are beautiful and with all that fiddling around you have suggested it would be next to impossible to chat or enjoy the landscapes and day-night changes in each spot. "The Burning Wall" after a rainy night when the sun rises...sigh it's great. After all this isn't "Pro Bass Fishing" don't most normal people just grab some worms and go sit next to some water and fish?