So after reading your entire post, here are my thoughts...
You're a tank, you're not supposed to deal a lot of damage. Again, you said you worked for an MMO and you claimed to have played MMOs for over 30 years (yeah...) yet you don't seem to know anything about them.
You call yourself a hardcore gamer, and you still don't even have full Darklight or a relic by this point?
"Huge impact"? No. Because nobody cares.
What are you even talking about? Are you saying tanks should deal more damage than the actual damage dealers, while still being incredibly defensive? Then what is the point of having damage dealers in the first place?You keep saying "in WoW...", yet you also said "if I wanted to play WoW, I'd go play WoW".You complain about the ability Cover and want it to automatically apply on a friendly player. On my paladin I've got a macro that casts Cover on the enemy's target. So if I lose enmity on a mob, I'll just press my macro while targeting that mob, and it'll cast Cover on the player. Try it.
I don't understand your logic.
You keep saying you don't want the game to feel like other games (WoW in particular), but you also keep saying you want the game to feel like other games...
Because you're lazy? Seriously though, that is not needed at all.
Why would you spam a non-combo Rage of Halone..? :/
...
Yeah, no.
Because you're not Cecil... Again, you are playing Final Fantasy XIV, not one of the previous games.
Nope!
It doesn't matter how fun the class is, tanks will ALWAYS be the least played class in any MMO, I figured you'd know that by now, having played MMOs for over 30 years and all... Anyways, I've got a lv 50 warrior, a lv 41 paladin (which I'm currently leveling) and another lv 40 paladin and I absolutely love both of the classes. From what I can read in your post, it seems like you'd much rather play a monk... (powerful attacks, shorter global cooldown, limit break etc.)![]()