Quote Originally Posted by OmegaSinX View Post
I would agree with you if the average Warrior Did 60-75% DPS of a Pure DPS . But you are fully Spec STR with Pure STR DPS Accessories (Striking & Maiming) which is only ideal in content that you are over geared for. Realistically the average War DPS is about 50% of pure DPS while in Defiance (without sacraficing alot of VIT and Parry for STR build like yours).
Except that I have all of my points in VIT and only hit the 75% mark when using full DPS accs (and, even then, not crafted ones; just the offspec ones I've gotten from raiding). I regularly manage 60-65% of a DPS while in full tank gear.

Also, I think its kinda contradicting of you to say that WAR DPS is OP and should not be buffed but then intentionally try to max your WAR DPS.
No, contradicting myself would be saying WAR DPS is OP and then further suggesting that WAR DPS be buffed. Balance and optimization are completely different constructs. Balance is a development concept whereas optimization is a player concept (though, keep in mind, optimization must be kept in mind for balance). I maximize my DPS while maximizing my survivability because that's the way to make myself as effective of a tank as possible. The only way that it has anything to do with balance is the relative performance between my optimized performance and those of other classes, which serves as a gauge to ascertain whether WAR needs to be changed.

But my point is the suggested change to Inner Beast was aimed more to be a QoL change . If a WAR really wants to push DPS, he will drop defiance all together.
Then why does Inner Beast deal any damage at all? Damage might not be the primary goal of a tank, but it's still a consideration. It's not a question of whether a WAR wants to push and maximize current DPS but whether it increases DPS while the WAR is tanking. Taking it off the GCD while keeping the damage as is would increase DPS while tanking any time that you were tanking. It doesn't matter if a WAR could turn off Defiance to do more damage because I'm not talking about a WAR dropping Defiance to max damage. I'm talking about the increase to damage that a WAR *not* trying to maximize damage would get because your change increases damage along with the usability of IB.

Your entire problem is that you seem to care more about keeping IB the same while only changing one aspect of it instead of trying to maintain the performance of the class as a whole while only changing how one ability is used. Simply taking IB off of the GCD without changing its damage increases WAR damage. It doesn't matter if you think that it's a small change or not because it's an increase to damage no matter what. Reducing the damage by half and doubling the self heal keeps the damage and self-heal almost exactly the same while having the same QoL improvement.

As an example, imagine putting Brutal Swing onto the GCD. It's only 50 potency, which is horrible for an on-GCD ability, even if it's a stun. It make up for the decreased value of it being an on-GCD attack, its damage would need to be increased to maintain the current level of performance (which provides an extra 6.25 potency per GCD). The exact same process is true when discussing taking IB off of the GCD: its damage needs to be lowered to maintain the current level of performance. The only reason *not* to change the damage/self-healing would be if you believe that WAR needs more damage.