Dont forget stats!!!

[Rydin]

I can't wait until the formulae are redone to make all stats function as intended
There are just so many stats that factor into everything....

Say a Plains footpad hits you with Luminous Spire... Its Astral damage....
So thats Fire, Wind and lightning

First and foremost It would be the Footpads Piety vs your own piety to decide whether it will be resisted

Then its the Footpads Int vs your Mind

followed by the footpads Magic Potency vs your magic defense

Then The game looks at each elemental attribute that applies to said spell....
(There is also some confusion with this one.... Some people say high fire element helps take less damage from fire spells... I've heard others say High Wind element helps defend against fire spells since wind beats fire...)
So there are at least 3 elemental attributes from the footpad vs either 3 elements of yours... OR the Elemental Resistances value (Which is given as one number as opposed to individual resistances for each element) or possibly even a formula involving both Elemental Attributes AND your elemental resistances

Shell's Magic damage modifier is applied, if applicable

No one knows where the Delta(Rank) modifier exists in the formula.. if not in several places, possibly even capping other values

Then after all of this is done, The damage is subtracted from your HP as determined by your vitality stat

Any shock spikes or Punishing barbs counter damage is calculated (as another set of calculations)

Its easy to see how a formula involving this many factors and variables can become too complex and contain unbalanced values....

Keep in mind, an RPG (MMO or otherwise) needs a very in depth damage formula, as that is the cornerstone of your game
But It will be nice when all of these values have a more clear meaning

[EinSof]

I want a luck stat and gambling minigames...

[Rydin]

I want a luck stat and gambling minigames...

Would luck stat effect every dice roll giving it a weighted system?

[EinSof]

Would luck stat effect every dice roll giving it a weighted system?

hahaha idk but it would be funny...

[Adol]

Speaking of stats, I hope they haven't forgotten about cooking and the bonus effects that food should give. Food is still pretty useless and culinarian is an unpopular craft to rank up because it never makes profits or anything which can be deemed useful.

[Rydin]

Speaking of stats, I hope they haven't forgotten about cooking and the bonus effects that food should give. Food is still pretty useless and culinarian is an unpopular craft to rank up because it never makes profits or anything which can be deemed useful.

Exactly... I want more than just some HP from my knight's Bread

[Perrin_Aybarra]

yeah I agree it will be nice when we can start to quantify the value of those stats and when they are all usefull in some ways.

Just want to point out for your fire element exemple, higher water would be more appropriate than wind:

Wind > Earth > Lightning > Water > Fire > Ice > Wind
read ">" like "beats"

So Fire is what you use against Ice, Wind you use against Ice, not fire. Water would beat fire. So if you want to resist fire more you need a great Water affinity (in your exemple). I myself am not sure if having more fire affinity or water affinity would be more beneficial as it stands now.

[Rydin]

"Fire melts ice, but is extinguished by wind"
"Ice obstructs wind, but is melted by fire"
"Wind Extinguishes Fire, but is obstructed by Ice."
Direct from the aetherytes
Fire > Ice > Wind > Fire

"Earth grounds lightning, but is eroded by water."
"Lightning boils water, but is grounded by earth"
"Water erodes earth, but is boiled by lightning"
which means
Earth > Lightning > Water > Earth

the most weird one is that Ice beats wind... but go figure

[Perrin_Aybarra]

"Fire melts ice, but is extinguished by wind"
"Ice obstructs wind, but is melted by fire"
"Wind Extinguishes Fire, but is obstructed by Ice."
Direct from the aetherytes
Fire > Ice > Wind > Fire

"Earth grounds lightning, but is eroded by water."
"Lightning boils water, but is grounded by earth"
"Water erodes earth, but is boiled by lightning"
which means
Earth > Lightning > Water > Earth

the most weird one is that Ice beats wind... but go figure

Oh sorry I didn't know they changed it in this game... I was going off memory in FFXI lol ; ;

I find it weird that they have 2 different circles, one light one dark I would assume but still...

Yeah Ice beating wind is strange but was like that before. "Ice obstructs wind, but is melted by fire"
makes sense, a big wall of ice obstruct the gust, no?

[Rydin]

Oh sorry I didn't know they changed it in this game... I was going off memory in FFXI lol ; ;

I find it weird that they have 2 different circles, one light one dark I would assume but still...

Yeah Ice beating wind is strange but was like that before. "Ice obstructs wind, but is melted by fire"
makes sense, a big wall of ice obstruct the gust, no?

Its weird that its not light and dark either....
Fire, Wind and Lightning are Astral.. and it makes sense, they are all "Sky" based elements

Earth, Ice and Water are the Umbral elements and they seem more terrestrial based

But the elemental hierarchy isn't split like that, it's weird