Are melee jobs as hated on every other server?

[dark494]

Every day I can be sure that when I log on and look at the party finder, I will see dozens of parties looking to do end-game content, like ex primals and coil, that restrict all the dps slots to *RANGED* dps only! Is this how it works now? Melee jobs are just outcasts of society and shunned from content just because they can? Is it because there are a bunch of people running around permeating the notion that all melee suck and die to every aoe and ability?

Please tell me I'm wrong, that other servers don't look so unfavorably on melee classes, because this is so depressing to see I question why we even have melee jobs in the first place. Everything has been proven to be clear-able without melee, so is there any point to even playing one?

[mythicrose]

Only time I've seen "no melee" on Cactuar has been for Garuda extreme mode. I've seen a few Titan extreme party finders not wanting black mages as well.

[axemtitanium]

A good monk will out-dps a good blm or smn every single time. I always take a melee for Titan X and Ifrit X. The problem is not the good monks, but the bad monks who don't know their rotation, don't know how to dodge, and don't know how to maintain uptime giving the best dps class a bad name.

[Swishytail]

A good monk will out-dps a good blm or smn every single time.

^ This pretty much. It's just people wanting to be lazy and cheese all the content with all ranged.

Show some love, people!

[Dervy]

but the bad monks

Exactly.

Unfortunately, bad melee players stick out a lot more than bad range players. They see the amount of times melee dps fail (as they're more prone to attacks) and everyone automatically don't want them in their team.

It's the same with BLMs on Titan. People see how poor, bad BLMs are at Titan EX, so they automatically assume all BLMs are terrible at Titan EX.

In truth, I've seen good BLM's wreck Titan EX, and good Melee DPS out play BRDs at Garuda EX.

[Fadigre]

A good monk will out-dps a good blm or smn every single time. I always take a melee for Titan X and Ifrit X. The problem is not the good monks, but the bad monks who don't know their rotation, don't know how to dodge, and don't know how to maintain uptime giving the best dps class a bad name.

Or even better, totally ignore Monk because it doesn't use Piercing damage.
Instead take one Dragoon for Disembowel and a bunch of Bards.

Sorry Monk, but you're only ever good for beating on Atomos.

[myahele]

Can't ssay about my server, but as a healer I don't like melee dps

[AmyNeudaiz]

I love playing with some melee in the party (as a healer at that) and there are toooooooons of them on Excalibur. I actually have a really good Mnk in my coil static and we love his DPS. We always make him go Mnk.

EDIT:

Saying that a MNK will out-dps X job every single time is incredibly ignorant. There are many fights that favor ranged dps over melee, not to mention that people seem to overestimate MNK dps to begin with.

Essentially, there is no fight that 'requires' melee dps, so why use it? Sure you can use melee dps in coil groups that don't suck, but in PUGs, you might as well use all ranged to lessen the chance of failure.

I started to agree with you with the bit about Mnk out DPSing other classes as some fights even Drg can out DPS Mnk in single target and it's very situational what class can out DPS what but you completely lost me on the second half of your post. Sure no fight *requires* melee but it makes a LOT of them easier.

Most melees can't seem to dodge from my experience doing Garuda Ex. Good ones are rare so I've become anti-melee lately.

I actually run into more bad ranged than bad melee. Maybe I'm just lucky (unlucky?) with that but I find that they tend to pick up mechanics slower and get tunnel vision easier due to having it "easy".

[Billzey]

Saying that a MNK will out-dps X job every single time is incredibly ignorant. There are many fights that favor ranged dps over melee, not to mention that people seem to overestimate MNK dps to begin with.

Essentially, there is no fight that 'requires' melee dps, so why use it? Sure you can use melee dps in coil groups that don't suck, but in PUGs, you might as well use all ranged to lessen the chance of failure.

[Swishytail]

Saying that a MNK will out-dps X job every single time is incredibly ignorant. There are many fights that favor ranged dps over melee, not to mention that people seem to overestimate MNK dps to begin with.

Essentially, there is no fight that 'requires' melee dps, so why use it? Sure you can use melee dps in coil groups that don't suck, but in PUGs, you might as well use all ranged to lessen the chance of failure.

Talking about ignorant then saying only use ranged. May as well just get rid of melee from the entire MMO if that's the case.
Why bother? Just let everyone pewpew from far away on every class/job.