Kick fuction being abused, based on a "meter".

[Kyata]

Could be that he neglected to count your faerie's healing as part of your score? Either that or he was just pulling numbers out of his taint to get rid of the one he blamed for the fail. I'm leaning toward the latter.

I'd say it's because of the other healer was spamming Medica, as was mentioned. That's like WARs getting 250+ dps because they spammed Overpower on a bunch of mobs.