Am I the only person on this planet who loves both games?!

I think XI and XIV are great in completely different ways. They're so night and day different that even comparing the 2 seems pretty redundant.

Sure I'd LOVE to play game with the sense of danger and atmosphere like XI someday but does it mean I can't enjoy a game like XIV?
The close mindedness of frankly both groups in this battle saddens me. If you can see good in only one or the other then trust me you're denyong yourself from having great gamin experiences and memories.