There was an argument there that you conveniently ignored just because I also called it dumb. Your post was strictly ad populum followed by a strawman.

I'm not assuming other jobs won't have the same problem. I only brought up a HYPOTHETICAL to show that, in the case of a class having two jobs that share a stat on the same class, they won't be gimped in the same way that people are saying SCH/SMN deserve to be gimped.

On the other hand, in order to say that SMN/SCH deserve to have to deal with this stupid stat system, you have to assume that EVERY SINGLE NEW JOB will have to deal with it too.