Gathering Classes & 'Item Fatigue'

[SeleneVenizelos]

Dragonhead and Ironlake (and Treespeak/Halitali) are both G5 so there shouldn't be any difference at all in SP gain. only item pools.

SP per gather, indeed not, however (although I am yet to try Halatali at any large scale due to the overwhelming urge to never set foot in or around Thanalan ever again) harvesting nodes are much closer together at DH & IL than at Treespeak, meaning you can bounce between two harvesting spots and the nearest tree. They are infact so close at IL that you can see the other harvesting node from the other. Due to the lack of running up and down slopes and bridges, I favour DH & IL over Treespeak as well. All that running time adds up!

The slopes play havoc with Triangulate V as well, and DH & IL is relatively flat / narrow.

[TheVedis]

SP per gather, indeed not, however (although I am yet to try Halatali at any large scale due to the overwhelming urge to never set foot in or around Thanalan ever again) harvesting nodes are much closer together at DH & IL than at Treespeak, meaning you can bounce between two harvesting spots and the nearest tree. They are infact so close at IL that you can see the other harvesting node from the other. Due to the lack of running up and down slopes and bridges, I favour DH & IL over Treespeak as well. All that running time adds up!

The slopes play havoc with Triangulate V as well, and DH & IL is relatively flat / narrow.

they arent close at treespeak?

LOL yes they are, closer then anywhere ive seen

on besaid we got 5 nodes up within 50 yards of each other right now

[Viridiana]

Note that functionally those numbers (2500 1000 100 10) are pretty much the same as (250 100 10 1). If it matters to you. And also note it only subtracts from your gathering points on a successful gather. and not number of items, but number of successful gathers.

Dragonhead and Ironlake (and Treespeak/Halitali) are both G5 so there shouldn't be any difference at all in SP gain. only item pools.

By the same token, Guardian Aspect is needlessly multiplied by 10, too. Giving us 20 and having it regen at a rate of 1 would be the same thing, the numbers just look smaller. . .

[SeleneVenizelos]

they arent close at treespeak?

LOL yes they are, closer then anywhere ive seen

on besaid we got 5 nodes up within 50 yards of each other right now

Right now being the important part of that sentence. If the server decides to load one all the way to the NW, E and SW, it's much harder. Imagine trying to find a rythm with that setup without Arbor Call V. That's why IL & DH is better for me, because I can rely on the harvesting spots to always be there and base my gathering from them. If I get lucky with node pops near them, I can average 20k per hour, as it takes me about three minutes at the most to complete a loop. Not exactly terrible, is it?

The harvesting spots at IL & DH are close enough that, but for a giant rock at DH, you could see the spots from one another. At Treespeak they are spaced much further from each other, making it much more difficult to find a rhythm without ACV. Previous experience has unfortunately been bad with Treespeak. When I get ACV I'll give it another go, but for now, I'm content with 20k an hour that I know I can get next to every time. =)

[TheVedis]

Right now being the important part of that sentence. If the server decides to load one all the way to the NW, E and SW, it's much harder. Imagine trying to find a rythm with that setup without Arbor Call V. That's why IL & DH is better for me, because I can rely on the harvesting spots to always be there and base my gathering from them. If I get lucky with node pops near them, I can average 20k per hour, as it takes me about three minutes at the most to complete a loop. Not exactly terrible, is it?

The harvesting spots at IL & DH are close enough that, but for a giant rock at DH, you could see the spots from one another. At Treespeak they are spaced much further from each other, making it much more difficult to find a rhythm without ACV. Previous experience has unfortunately been bad with Treespeak. When I get ACV I'll give it another go, but for now, I'm content with 20k an hour that I know I can get next to every time. =)

they are close together fairly often though
so i dont see how you cant find them that close

[SeleneVenizelos]

they are close together fairly often though
so i dont see how you cant find them that close

Just unlucky I guess.

Actually, to clarify, I'm referring to the harvesting spots (literally just those, the things you farm with the scythes) when I say DH & IL are much closer; which they are, they never move around. I think there was another misunderstanding somewhere, if that's my fault I apologise. You just need to take most of what I say into a failure-like context of not having Arbor Call V, lol.

[TheVedis]

Just unlucky I guess.

Actually, to clarify, I'm referring to the harvesting spots (literally just those, the things you farm with the scythes) when I say DH & IL are much closer; which they are, they never move around. I think there was another misunderstanding somewhere, if that's my fault I apologise. You just need to take most of what I say into a failure-like context of not having Arbor Call V, lol.

yeah those are spread out

you got the 2 right next to each other in the north sector, and sometimes nodes spawn next to them to make it convenient

[SeleneVenizelos]

yeah those are spread out

you got the 2 right next to each other in the north sector, and sometimes nodes spawn next to them to make it convenient

On the few occasions I tried there I didn't have any luck, had a rather inconvenient treck to get anything, really killed my SP/hour. The problem was not being able to know exactly where the trees were, so will definitely give it a try once I have ACV.