Results 1 to 10 of 152

Thread: Warrior Tanking

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Nalou's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Posts
    124
    Character
    Oulan Bator
    World
    Ragnarok
    Main Class
    Marauder Lv 50
    Quote Originally Posted by Kitru View Post
    A class is defined by its playstyle, not by the mechanics used. WAR has always been defined by Wrath generation and management rather than the self healing that you (and many other people) focused upon to the exclusion of pretty much anything else.
    Actually no. Proactive tanking vs reactive tanking is a playstyle, more than a mechanic.
    2.0 warrior was waiting for spike damage to happen THEN popped Inner Beast to recover.
    2.1 warrior tries to pop Inner Beast BEFORE the damage to reduce it (which is a lot harder, you cannot simply hold on wrath till something happen, you have to know when something happens and anticipate). This impacts the way a warrior manages wrath, because the goal is now to have wrath built for specific points in the fight.
    So the playstyle changed.

    Let's say we switch Inner Beast on a 20s CD with no wrath involved. The mechanics would be different (no wrath to manage), but the playstyle of the class would pretty much be the same: chain combos for enmity, debuff, buff and pop special ability.

    So the nature of Inner Beast (reactive or proactive) is a playstyle.
    The mechanic is building wrath or dealing with another resource like timers, tp or mp.
    (1)

  2. #2
    Player
    Hitokirinomad's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    55
    Character
    Vyctoria Elizabeth
    World
    Famfrit
    Main Class
    Archer Lv 91
    Quote Originally Posted by Nalou View Post
    Actually no. Proactive tanking vs reactive tanking is a playstyle, more than a mechanic.
    2.0 warrior was waiting for spike damage to happen THEN popped Inner Beast to recover.
    2.1 warrior tries to pop Inner Beast BEFORE the damage to reduce it (which is a lot harder, you cannot simply hold on wrath till something happen, you have to know when something happens and anticipate). This impacts the way a warrior manages wrath, because the goal is now to have wrath built for specific points in the fight.
    So the playstyle changed.

    Let's say we switch Inner Beast on a 20s CD with no wrath involved. The mechanics would be different (no wrath to manage), but the playstyle of the class would pretty much be the same: chain combos for enmity, debuff, buff and pop special ability.

    So the nature of Inner Beast (reactive or proactive) is a playstyle.
    The mechanic is building wrath or dealing with another resource like timers, tp or mp.
    lI rejoiced to see a logical argument against Kitru on these forums, because the fact that it *can* be done resonates in my soul.

    However I disagree. The crux of the argument is the same as the 'WAR is built around self-healing'. Inner Beast. Inner Beast is one skill that does not truly define the playstyle as reactive. The only difference between the *timing* of Inner Beast now and then, if the delay of one GCD. You still had to get your stacks up or Infuriate before the big hit, you just fired the IB in the GCD after the hit. Now you fire it off the GCD before the hit. You still have to know the hit is coming, you still have to preemptively prepare your resource (be proactive). Heck, if there are no fights with a timed big hit, you get to use IB even more because you don't have to worry about the overheal. Generally speaking, none of the other WAR skills are as useful reactively (ToB can be used before or after, but using it before prevents the OHKO).

    The reason that Kitru says that WAR is centered around wrath stacks is BECAUSE of the last line of your post. Wrath is another resource like timers or MP...which you use to increase your damage, do a big AOE hit, or increase your mitigation. It's also an exclusive resource to WAR, which strongly suggests it's what the class is built around (versus one skill that is consumed by said resource). DRG = Jumps, MNK = GL, WAR = Wrath. Losing the requirement to manage wrath would drastically change the playstyle of the class because those stacks are a limited resource that you have to have up when you need them, and have to make the choice on the proper skill to use them on. If WAR didn't manage wrath, then SC = CoS, Unchained = Extraneous DPS Cooldown, and WAR >> PLD.
    (0)
    Last edited by Hitokirinomad; 01-27-2014 at 12:05 AM.