Quote Originally Posted by Traek View Post
Woa woa WOAAAAA!! You are way over thinking this.
I don't think PiedPiper is.

Knowing you reduce damage by 35% when you successfully block with one shield and 25% with another tells you little. At first glance the 35% reduction seems better, but if you have a 15% block rate with it but the other has a 25% chance of blocking.

The resulting mitigation from the first shield (35%/15%) is 5.25% while the second shield (25%/25%) is 6.25%.