• Allagan Round Shield - STR9 / VIT10 / ACC7 / PARRY11 (181/181)
  • Holy Shield Zenith - STR9 / VIT10 / SKLLSPD7 / PARRY11 (181/181)
  • Onion Shield - STR9 / VIT10 / PARRY7 / CRIT11 (295/92)


Allagan Round Shield's ACC and PARRY values are most wanted stats especially going towards T5 coil where acc caps rise. As a tank you def don't want to be missing any hits.
For all other content, Holy Shield Zenith's Parry will be enough and the skill speed is a nice bump.

Onion shield however looks like it wants to be used as a DPS build, sacrificing parry for some crit and doing away with block strength in favor of more frequent smaller blocks. If i was a strict OT PLD for lets say DF Titan HM (2tanks), and I know id never MT or need to block big damage, ie mountain buster. Id use the Onion Shield rather Allagan Round Shield or Holy Shield Zenith.