Thread: How are warriors after 2.1?

Originally Posted by ProxyTooMuch

Going directly from Shield Oath to Sword Oath is bugged. You keep the mega enmity bonus from Shield Oath and now also deal more damage.

Thanks for the confirmation! But I think it's a little more than that actually:

+ If both Paladin A and Paladin B toggle on Shield Oath and then Paladin B goes straight from Shield > Sword Oath, then Paladin B will pull hate.
+ However if Paladin A then switches into Sword Oath (to get the same buff as Paladin B) and then back to Shield Oath, then Paladin A will pull hate.

Certain Tanks have also reported not receiving the +20% Damage Resistance Buff of Shield Oath upon zoning to a new instance.

I think what's happening is that the increased enmity from both stances is stacking with each other somehow (e.g. both Oaths grant separate enmity buffs, and neither is "going away" properly when stance swapping), plus that the stance buffs (-damage/+resistance and enmity increase alike) are not always being reapplied when zoning into a new instance.

That latter bit is important because there are reports from DPS classes that they have occasionally been able to pull hate off a Paladin as if they had no Shield Oath up at all - and whilst a tank being able to pull hate off another tank is mildly annoying, a tank that cannot hold hate over a DPS is a danger to the party.

I've been very, very, very OCD recently about always manually disabling and re-enabling Shield Oath at the start of every instance... now I'm tempted to flick to Sword Oath and back again as well...

Originally Posted by Maelwys

snip

I discovered this by accident while testing some enmity numbers and I can personally confirm it. If you hit shield oath and then enable sword oath OR just cancel shield oath, you will keep the 200% enmity until you change classes or change areas. If you start out with neither sword oath nor shield oath, you generate 100% enmity, and if you start out with only sword oath you generate 100% enmity.

Definitely a bug in my opinion.

Originally Posted by Maelwys

Flash part

Sorry had 75 characters over the limit so I snipped you.

Thats what we did during t2.
My gear is roughly equal to the other Paladin's. (his shield was better and his gloves).
But the enmity generation for him was lesser, he wasn't generating the same amount or coming close to it.
He always dropped further and further away.

Of course judging from the other posts, he hadn't swapped from shield oath to sword oath.