I really like the book too in fact the main reason why i chose to go scholar instead if whm was because of the book, plus compared to the cricket bats used by paladins and the bits of trees the whm/cnjs passes for wands and the backward coat hangers monks uses as fists i'd say the book isn't that bad =/. ( if its anything i'd say SE might want to reconsider their weapons design team xD) Although when it comes to the relics i can see what you mean everyone else's relic is much more interesting tbh i even think the summoner's relic is nice just the scholar's relic is a bit plain but the actual idea of a book for a weapon i think is awesome