Something needs to be done about elements

[Tzain]

The BLM spell list is kind of ridiculous. BLM should have access to the Elemental Wheel of Magics. Not just 3. Or they could have made it make sense, Black Mage, use "Dark Magic" like in XI. Which would be, Blizzard, Water, Stone and Dark and then give WHM the other; Fire, Lightning, Aero and Light.

Technically BLM only has access to Fire (Flare) and Ice (Freeze). THM has access to Fire, Ice, and Lightning. I seem to remember the first Class Quest text explaning the reason why they focus on those elements. Honestly, I've been a BLM for as long as I've been a WHM and I still have no clue what the BLM abilities are about. If you went by the Job Quests I'd be summoning Voidkin to do my bidding like a Warlock or something.

[SendohJin]

Or they could have made it make sense, Black Mage, use "Dark Magic" like in XI. Which would be, Blizzard, Water, Stone and Dark and then give WHM the other; Fire, Lightning, Aero and Light.

it is kind of like that though

BLM/THM has Fire, Ice, Thunder
WHM/CNJ has Earth, Wind, Water

but Fluid Aura being the only Water spell in the game is just hilarious.

[Mimilu]

My biggest problem with the lack of elemental resistance in this game is that it's led to a lack of variety in spells/skills for the classes/jobs.
Whenever I play this game, I have to compare it to XI, there are just to many parallels within the games not to, not to mention XI is XVI's senior in the FF series and the only other MMO in it.
XI had BLM with spell for each element, SMNs with summons for each element (which allowed the summons to be the main focus of the job), WHM having few offense light element spells to allow them to focus more on healing and buff spells, and Weapon Skills and Skill Links for your physical classes, followed by a nice Magic Burst from your nukers.
XVI's system is just so streamlined that it gets repetitive. All THM/BLM fling the same spell-rotations, all ACN/SMN place the same DoTs and use Garuda, CNJ/WHM barely ever use their offensive spells or buff during a battle, and the melee DPS barely need to interact and/or coordinate attacks with one another...

[Exstal]

Except XI is a glaring example of how not to make an MMO.

Also, you keep writing XVI (16) when you mean to write XIV (14).

[ruinedmirage]

Except XI is a glaring example of how not to make an MMO.

Also, you keep writing XVI (16) when you mean to write XIV (14).

I dunno. Over a decade and it's still a sub based game, being the biggest money maker in the FF franchise, and multiple threads on here saying that this game should be more like it......

I think you just forgot to write "IMO" in there somewhere.

[Deusteele]

Except there never was any real interplay between elements in any Final Fantasy. It was pick whatever element the enemy is weak against and spam that.

[Cegiana]

it is kind of like that though

BLM/THM has Fire, Ice, Thunder
WHM/CNJ has Earth, Wind, Water

but Fluid Aura being the only Water spell in the game is just hilarious.

midway through Legacy FFXIV's lifespan, the new team redid the magic setup. CNJ had ALL the elements including multiple water spells, but the new team split the spells between THM and CNJ and got rid of most of THMs spell (man do I miss shock spikes.) While they were splitting it, they ended up not giving Water to any of them. So the later half of Legacy FFXIV we did not have any water spells, but enemies did. They had gear to enhance our water spells yet none existed anymore. lol What was also funny was that, even though CNJ no longer had half of the elements, the storyline was never changed to reflect that, so it would still tell you that CNJ were in charge of elements that now belonged to THM. In ARR the CNJ storyline now only mentions the elements that belong to CNJ. THM was truly bad ass in 1.0 until the new team got rid of most THM spells, I remember THM was a monster and killing things in ways that make ACN seem underpowered in comparison. lol

Ah memories, cause that's all it is now, distant memories. But then again, we didn't have any MP regeneration at all back then, would have to touch an Aetheryte to get back MP, so even though things didn't use up much MP, you had to be very careful to not cast any spell that didn't need to be cast. So yeah, some are good memories and some not that good.

I dunno. Over a decade and it's still a sub based game, being the biggest money maker in the FF franchise, and multiple threads on here saying that this game should be more like it......

I still play FFXI (3 subs and 18 characters, 10 are mules though) and FFXI is becoming more and more like FFXIV with every update. For example, it's super solo now cause you can have 3 Trust Companions out with you (Famous NPCs that fight with you.) Notorious Monsters pop MUCH faster and they drop their rewards at a DRASTICALLY increased rate. They added timed events that (somewhat) resemble FATEs. They added a ton of town crystals and now you can teleport from area to area like in FFXIV or even to other towns by paying gil, just like FFXIV, even to far off/difficult to reach areas, just like FFXIV. They even considered having the doors open automatically like in FFXIV (couldnt do it cause the door clicking is related to many quests, but they tried to add it.) In FFXI you can now pick the difficulty of certain content just like certain content in FFXIV. Even the UI is being redone to make it more efficient. FFXI even does item levels like FFXIV (although FFXI had it first.) And that's just stuff off the top of my head. Face it people, FFXI's abusive systems are a thing of the past, they want it to be as fun as FFXIV is and they are well past the idea/planning stage, it is already being implemented and it's not gonna stop (until the game goes offline forever and with 500-1,200 people on when I log in, it's not going away anytime soon.)

[Kitru]

I dunno. Over a decade and it's still a sub based game, being the biggest money maker in the FF franchise, and multiple threads on here saying that this game should be more like it

Let me refute each of those.

It's been around for over a decade with consistent development and support from its parent company. This is why it makes so much money: not because it is a good game, but because it is a long standing MMO that gets continual development. MMOs fail when they stagnate. You have to keep developing a game in order to keep people playing it. This is the *one* thing that FFXI has done well, but it has nothing to do with the game design and more to do with the business management.

The fact that it is a subscription game falls within this same category: people are willing to pay $15 a month if the game gets updated regularly, even if the content is mostly crap. Novelty is a huge factor.

On top of this, it also arrived when the MMO market was still pretty immature (it was released in 2002; WoW, which during the Vanilla days, made a *crapton* of horrible design decisions because they didn't know any better, was released in late 2004) and, much like WoW, got a *lot* of attention because of the cache of its name and the accompanying series. A preexisting fan base means that the developers have immediate access to a massive potential player base without having to put forth the effort to get attention. It's why WoW, SWTOR, EQ2, and WHO all had very large release numbers. FFXI had more of this than any other MMO ever released because the FF series has had a *very* loyal playerbase going back for over *20 years*.

As to the people saying that ARR should be more like XI, that's not due to the quality of XI; it's due to the fact that the average person is deeply uncomfortable with change. ARR has a dramatically different system than XI *or* XIV1.0. Even if the system were absolutely perfect in every possible way, people would get upset because it deviates from what they were used to in previous games. It doesn't help that a lot of people live under the absurd notion that you never have to make compromises when developing certain systems. It's also why FFXI has so many players; there are 2 basic varieties of players: long haul gamers, which will play for years as long as you don't screw the game up, and short term gamers, which will play for a couple months before they get bored. Once a game hits the 3-4 month mark, the short term gamers leave and the long haul gamers stick around and, most of the time, they'll stick around *forever*. The combination of these two elements of the same basic idea converge to explain XI's "superiority" to XIV: you've had a bunch of people that have played a given game for years on end with a poorly constructed system that they are incredibly used to switching to a new game that uses a different system. It's not that XI is superior to XIV; it's that those people are more used to it and they want anything they play to be either a minor deviation from what they're used to or simply the same system with a new story or development push.

One of the threads you're referring to talks about the lack of elemental weaknesses to exploit, which has been something that's deeply set within the FF series. The problem with this (which WoW found out very early on in Vanilla, with all of their endgame raids devoted to basically a single element, the major ones of which were fire) is that it prevents the creation a relatively simple but still compelling play experience. In effect, you're either going to two of these three: a manageable number of abilities, a system that allows for appreciable elemental weakness/strengths, and an interesting and compelling implementation of the combat system. Look at how BLM is designed: it's one of the most fun implementations of an offensive caster that I've seen. It's elegant in its design and fun in execution. The only way you'd be able to use that same playstyle while allowing for elemental weaknesses and strengths would be to create 3-6 times the number of abilities, since you'd need to allow access to all elements while preventing one of the phase aspects of BLM to be rendered redundant (i.e. you would need to allow for variant element Astral Fire spells, variant element Umbral Ice spells, and variant element Thunder/Thundercloud spells in sufficient numbers to cover all elements). Even so, you would have incredible amounts of redundancy when you don't have to worry about elemental resistances weaknesses and, when you do, since there are so many spells, you have to tweak your bars/rotation/keybinds to cover that specific set of elemental weaknesses and strengths. It preserves the playstyle and implements the weakness/resistances, but you end up with so many spells and so much non-combat ability management that it becomes untenable for anyone who doesn't enjoy regular UI manipulation.

There are a *lot* of people that misunderstand certain aspects of ARR and *why* they are good design decisions implemented because the developers were aware of the bad design decisions of other games. ARR has single role jobs/classes because it gives them stronger control over role population. ARR has very little intraclass/interclass customization because other games that *do* allow for such customization just end up with optimized cookie cutter builds that everyone goes with and anyone that deviates from them is denigrated for being substandard; in effect, the only choice you have in those games is whether you're going to be effective and identical or substandard and different.

ARR did away with the aspects of MMOs that developers and players wrongfully considered to be good design. It has been found out that talent trees are not good game design. It has been found out that allowing for multiple roles within a single class that, while not outright *bad*, is not especially *good* game design. ARR doesn't have open world end game or open world PvP because, once again, it's not good game design. So very, very many things about ARR were done because the devs took an objective look at what benefits and what baggage those elements of play brought with them. Rather than bringing them in because they sounded good or because that's just how things had always been done, they actually thought about the problems/goals and considered variant/non-standard designs that would allow them to do so with fewer problems while fulfilling the same goals (especially fulfilling those goals without the pretense and self-delusion of illusory choice proffered by so very many "customization" schemes).

Hell, I honestly believe that the implementation of ARR's endgame and group content development is the absolute best of any MMO I've ever played: the primal trials are boss fights without the arbitrary trash cluttering everything and you can repeat them as much as you want (which is *awesome* and largely without precedent); coil is a standard weekly dungeon with all of the stuff you'd expect implemented in a way that allows comparatively casual players to take part as well (since it doesn't lock you to a group); CT is a very interesting variation on the standard weekly dungeon because you can run it indefinitely but you can only get a single piece of loot per week. Anyone that claims that ARR's endgame should be more like FFXI needs to be put in a sack, have the sack thrown into a river, and have the river lit on fire. Camping certain spawn points for hours on end and getting into boss fights intended to last hours at a time for the "fast" kill is not good design. Sitting around doing nothing isn't fun, especially when your time can be quickly wasted because someone else got the first hit instead of you.

Basically, there are 2 reasons that FFXI is still considered a success: it's part of the FF series and it's been around long enough that there is tremendous inertia in the playerbase. Neither of those have anything to do with it begin a good game. *Many* commercial successes are completely bland games that were just marketed well or require negligible development with a ludicrously loyal and/or large potential player base (just look at people that play CoD or any sports video game: sports games are still basically the same as they were in the NES days and FPSs haven't really changed since Doom; the only real difference is just the improved graphics).

[Nakiamiie]

I, too, feel there is a huge lackluster on the elemental weaknesses/resistance in this game.

The way I see it, the elemental resistance/weaknesses shouldn't be about damage but bonus effects.

For example, a fire monster/boss. So attacking it with its opposite could give a small perk, such as self-heal penalty, a slow effect, etc.
An extra effect you wouldn't get otherwise. And that effect would tip the fight that much would still help a bit (especially considering the monsters/bosses build up immunity).

As for players, same. Boosting an elemental resistance would also boost a status resistance (sleep, slow, silence, ...)

That would allow to have a more meaningful elemental feature in the game, while leaving it somewhat underpowered as the developers wanted (and some players want).

Simply hovering your cursor over the element in your profile window would display which status is tied with what element.

What do you think?

N.B.: Also, by being able to pick up attacks from other classes, it would allow other jobs/classes to have access to some elemental spells too. So it wouldn't be restricted to BLM/WHM.

[matic]

Let me refute each of those.

you really do like walls of text.

anyway, you've oversimplified and editorialized a CRAPTON. I don't actually disagree with the whole point of your argument (XI is tremendously outdated) but you're using phrases like "found to be good game design" when what you mean is "found to be safe game design" or even "found to be the popular contemporary idea of good game design"

if you honestly think open world pve and pvp is bad design you're crazy. ARR did a lot of smart things, but it also lost a lot of what makes MMOs fun in the process of streamlining and making the game accessible to all. I don't have a problem with this for the most part, and i certainly am not in the XI-Luddite camp, but at least be realistic and recognize that a lot of ARR's features come with a price.


oh, also your entire last paragraph is just out and out wrong, or at the very least, choking on hyperbole.