Commendation System: So who get's your vote?

[Megido]

1. Person that stated they were new to the dungeon or new to the role at the start and performed well, listening to all advice.
2. Person giving advice/strategy effectively and patient with new people. (#1 if I'm the one that's new)

Wait, you are giving your commend to the guy that has no clue of the place, over the guy that DOES have a clue and is spending time helping out the new guy?
Oh man imagine how screwed over he'll feel when he doesnt even get commends for it. Great idea if you dont want knowledgeable lvl50 tanks in your low lvl dungeons.