Commendation System: So who get's your vote?

[Cons]

I give to both the exceptional and the unfortunate

[LalaRu]

I will give them after excluding:
- id***s (yo armor is LOL I'm teh best!)
- elitists (omg a noob! votekik! I leave!)
- bisches (fudging tank! l2aggro! / Where is teh healer? / Yo dps too low! l2dps!)

Then IF someone still commendable , I'll go by sympaty, if tank, I'll be grateful to the healer who kept me alive, if cannot decide, I'll wait until there is only one to commend

[Cuurad]

im a tank, and most time ill give my vote to the heal. But, when he/she is an elitare, "noob" cryin`A**hole, then the vote goes to in my opinion well workin dps

[EinherjarLucian]

im a tank, and most time ill give my vote to the heal. But, when he/she is an elitare, "noob" cryin`A**hole, then the vote goes to in my opinion well workin dps

Pretty much the same here, but the other way around (I'm a healer primarily, so I tend to upvote the tank), unless a DD has done something spectacular or the tank is a jerk. Players who are helpful and friendly get bumped to the top of the list.

[Bahd_Monkey]

As a dps, unless someone does something exceptional, I'll commend the other dps.

When I go in with a small pre made party. I always tell the other players that we are in a party and can't commend them. I don't want them to think we are being rude, or didn't appreciate their help.

If members of a pre made party can't give commendations then maybe they shouldn't be able to receive them as well. And their names would be greyed out or not listed in the commendation window. That way non party members will know exactly what is going on. (Just my opinion)

[Simaril]

As a healer in 8 mans, if I screw up I make a point to give the other healer credit in /p. I've screwed up pretty bad, and done this, and received commendations myself! I assume the other healer is thanking me, but sometimes I get more than 1 when I know I screwed up bad... and I'm guessing if I had stayed quiet I'd get the 0 I deserved. It's really interesting how people handle commendations.

Players who screw up and know it, or have lag, yet I manage to keep up are often thankfull, and know the healer saved them... Those are the commendations that make me feel good

[PiedPiper]

You should always commend the tank. We are the ones who rescue you from your long queue time by deigning to run the dungeon. We are the limited supply, dps are just pawns that kill things for the tanks.

[Arkista]

You should always commend the tank. We are the ones who rescue you from your long queue time by deigning to run the dungeon. We are the limited supply, dps are just pawns that kill things for the tanks.

Nope cause I've gotten a lot of bad tanks and they don't get any. If they do a good job I will give them one. Don't know how but I get a lot while playing MNK, sometimes I get all 3. I wish I could give everyone in the party one, sometimes I get a really awesome group.

[Meimei]

You should always commend the tank. We are the ones who rescue you from your long queue time by deigning to run the dungeon. We are the limited supply, dps are just pawns that kill things for the tanks.

Ignore this one, children. Thou shalt not reward ineptitude and a poor job. Tanks already get spoon fed everything with instant pops - when they suck there's just no excuse.

Always prioritize your DPS, unless they sucked. But you can always just boot bad DPS and get new ones. Good DPS, however, are crucial for your smooth and speedy runs. Try and remember that. ♥

[WendyDarling]

if people are talkative i have a much higher chance of giving out a commendation. if the whole run is silent i dont give one out, why reward people in a multiplayer game for being anti-social? lol ya know?
i also tend to give tanks my commendation more often than i give it to the dps. they do a lot of work to keep me from pulling aggro with my heals. that being said, i do give them to dps once in a while, but they have to be friendly or stand out in some way. dps are a dime a dozen.
when i do dungeons i usually get 2 or 3 commendations per run so... that leads me to believe most people are giving them to the healer in the group.