This is just people getting butthurt from having bad groups or dying too much to stuff. I have killed all 3 primals several times now on my tank who is i90 but I can tell you this. even at i90 I can be killed very quickly from not being smart on any of these fights. BUT if I am smart. I can also tank these fights in Darklight and have seen it done with tanks in darklight. ifrit ...is not hard on tanks at all if your tanks aren't dumb. Switch whenever your debuff falls off. Leaves 2 or Less debuffs on the MT at all times and healers can take a real load off and focus on keeping the raid topped off and makes that fight 100% easier. Titan...doesn't even hurt, Time your cooldowns for bombs if you take them or Mbuster nough said. Garuda, Everytime the adds cast friction they do Wheel attack Pop 2 cooldowns as a pally and you litteraly take crap for dmg and can do it every time that phase comes up, and that is the ONLY part of that fight where there is any real dmg incoming to the tank.