Commendation system is useless

[Tlamila]

Best to wait for treasure to be distributed, give a 5-count, then head out. If they saw one warning to roll on an item, then they saw the warning to commend someone. They're right next to each other.

That's exactly what I do. REinding people to vote, to me would look like I'm asking for a vote, which is lame. The button is just over loot one.
Must say though, in pvp this doesn't apply...

[Ldlv]

Maybe it's not working for the english speakers community, because I see some people just leave asap in the end of the run without saying anything. But in the japanese community, they usually say 'otsukaresama' or 'pt arigatou' in the end of the run regardless of how bad the party performs, maybe SE gives out the commendation on top of it to reward someone who perform the best.

I agree that it feels kinda broken when someone already left, we cannot commend that person. It kinda force everyone to stay in the dungeon for a bit.

[Tlamila]

But in the japanese community, they usually say 'otsukaresama' or 'pt arigatou' in the end of the run regardless of how bad the party performs,

I usually see people saying at least "gj" or "ty" (more then two letteres is hard to write of course) unless they're jerks. But we should know that japanese have all a special culture about formalities and thanks and such.

My logic is, if someone already left their loss, I vote for who had the patience to wait. What saddens me is when all 3 have been equally good and I have to just pick a random one, while I'd want to vote them all.

[Gemma]

See good thing I looked at this I did my first DF roulette and I left before a few ppl so from now on I'll wait lol ^_^

[Jinrya-Geki]

Red Wizard for President! Vote for me!

If you vote for me, I promise to try and end duties I randomly end up in as fast as possible by blowing up mobs for you while not trying to pull agro!

[Ehayte]

TL;DR most of the thread, but @ OP - that sucks! In my experience most people stick around to vote!

Also, I think its AWESOME, my DF runs have been 100-1,000% more enjoyable since the implementation of it. I don't have to lead the dungeon 100% of the time, people that were silent before are speaking up and being more patient. I think its a total genius, almost cost-free incredible incentivizer so far!