List of mob elemental weakness?

[Xellotath]

There are mobs that drop 1-6 shards of multiple types , eg puk : http://ffxiv.yg.com/npc/cellar-puk?id=3100109 , so this can't be right.

Unfortunately YG is not infallible and as it's not a wiki that we can update ourselves it will never be as good as the FFXI wiki was.

That page is wrong, mobs will only drop 1-6 of one type of shard - the element they are alligned to. In the case of puks, that is Wind and you want to use Ice on them.

And yeah bombs are the exception as in all FF games they are weak to their own element, Fire.

[Sylkis]

Unfortunately YG is not infallible and as it's not a wiki that we can update ourselves it will never be as good as the FFXI wiki was.

That page is wrong, mobs will only drop 1-6 of one type of shard - the element they are alligned to. In the case of puks, that is Wind and you want to use Ice on them.

And yeah bombs are the exception as in all FF games they are weak to their own element, Fire.

No, its not wrong.
Proof: http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/...123/shards.png

Along with dropping fire and ice shards, star marmot will also drop earth shards.