I am for toggling auto attack on/off. That would make a happy medium. The only downside is if people that prefer one over the other it will prove to be an issue for end game companies - will the leaders prefer you to auto-attack or manually handle your attacks? I would say, if I were a leader, I would require manual handling. There are always crucial moments in a big fight that you kinda wish there was no auto-attack - especially if it is a long fight and people start getting bored while on auto-attack. At least with manual, you know if the person is actually there and not just pro-siphoning the experience/loot.

If it has to be in, toggle please. I do not want to be required to auto-attack. I have played too many mmorpgs with auto-attack. I like something a little different. Granted, I would say the only annoying part that gets to me is not being able to chat smoothly. I have to rush through what I say during attacks. haha However, the truth of the matter of that is - what am I doing chatting when I am suppose to be paying attention to what I am helping to kill?

Just my 2 cents!