Quote Originally Posted by Reynhart View Post
You can't count 25% HP due to damage mitigation AND 25% healing bonus for Shield Oath
So it's not 25% HP + 25% healing bonus > 25% HP + 20% healing bonus

It's 25% HP (Shield Oath) < 25% HP (Defiance HP bonus) + 20% healing (Defiance healing buff, no Rage V needed in 2.1)

So, Leiron's calculation was wrong and he should apologise to VoxInaBox.
This was covered by math in many other posts in the forums. Defiance needs to have 25% healing in order for it to EQUAL Shield Oath. Otherwise, Shield Oath is better (by a little bit)