Thread: MNK or DRG post 2.1

With the current mechanics and content in the game, MNKs are probably slightly more effective than DRGs for a few specific fringe reasons:

1. They do higher single target DPS. DRG AOE DPS is useful, but BLMs are also pretty common, and can sufficiently fill whatever AOE needs are there.

2. They have a few bits of pretty unique utility that DRGs don't have, like the %Int debuff in their rotation as well as the traited Mantra increased healing.

The main DRG utility benefits are the piercing debuff for Bards (who are a slightly behind in DPS in the first place), and the ability to tank some stuff a bit better, which doesn't matter much. DRG's also have slightly higher controllable burst damage, which has its uses.

Overall it's kind of a wash, but MNKs are more effective by a slight measure.

Originally Posted by EasymodeX

...the ability to tank some stuff a bit better, which doesn't matter much.

How are dragoons better tanks?

Originally Posted by Allyrion

DRG gear has higher defense. MNKs have higher M. Def.
So dragoons make better tanks.

Drgs have 10% reduced damage buff? Don't think they get that much extra armor.

Originally Posted by Rochetm

How are dragoons better tanks?

In some fights a DRG can be left to tank an add more reliably than a MNK. In those situations, a MNK "can" tank it fine, but they will require more healer attention, which is a detriment.

This scenario usually boils down to the fact that Keener Flurry is the shit.

I think BLM is the best dps tanks.

Drgs also always have Keen Flurry and Feint on *when feint works*. . . and Life Surge.

Which class is bettet for a ps3 user? That drg 27 combo looks like it just isnt possible on a ps3 hotbar with ui lag and having to switch between menus. Is mnk any different?

Originally Posted by trailmix9999

Which class is bettet for a ps3 user? That drg 27 combo looks like it just isnt possible on a ps3 hotbar with ui lag and having to switch between menus. Is mnk any different?

You must use two sets of bars on ps3 for both classes. You cannot get around it unless you want to be a bad monk/drg.