Quote Originally Posted by Garnatian View Post
So what it looks like, if we are to compare un-buffed WAR and PLD you have:

[...]

The 10% is somewhat of an assumption.
That would be incorrect. You are comparing tools with different uses. Defiance directly compares to Shield Oath as follows:

Shield Oath
+25% effective HP
+25% effective healing

Defiance
+25% effective HP
+20% effective healing

What you want to compare with Inner Beast is Rampart, which is more like 4.44% to 4.48% (neglecting Infuriate). That comparison is not really that valuable either, though. There's a lot that goes into it which I'm not going to discuss here -- need to run more math and all.