I'll support Hiromichi Tanaka regardless, How about You?

[Blair]

This may be a discussed thread, but I just want to say it out loud again:

Tanaka, Please come back or please work on the new MMO for SE!!!

Although so much people hate about you due to the failure launch of FFXIV.
I hate you not.

I respect a person with so much successful history ,
it means hard work, it means vision, it means talent!

So what if you made a mistake once or twice, there is something inside you that no one else can do it better than you!

I will give my full support to you personally. I'm sure there are people in this forum also support you with whole heart.

All the friends in this forum, I hope that you will also support Tanaka , for what he can create amazing stuff again in the future.

Below is from Wiki of Tanaka
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiromichi_Tanaka

Game creditsThe Death Trap (programmer)
Genesis (producer/scenario/game design)
Alpha
Suishō no Dragon
Yokohama Minato Renzoku Satsujin Jiken
Final Fantasy (game design)
Final Fantasy II (game design)
Final Fantasy III (game design)
Final Fantasy Legend II (game data)
Secret of Mana (producer, concept / System design, Scenario message data)
Seiken Densetsu 3 (director)
Xenogears (producer/battle design)
Chrono Cross (producer/battle design)
Threads of Fate (producer)
Final Fantasy XI and expansions (producer)
Final Fantasy III (DS version) (executive producer/director)
SaGa 2: Hihou Densetsu (DS version) (co-executive producer/general supervision)
Final Fantasy XIV (Prior to December 2010) (producer)

PS: I can't find Wiki of Yoshi, weirdd?

[Kailok]

I wouldn't mind if Tanaka worked on the new MMO, as long as the upper management allows him the time needed to complete it.

[Verecund]

There is more that is limiting this game's development than simply who is "in charge." Personally, I'll support any one that didn't decide to release this game so prematurely. :P

[Dragon]

If he brings his vision to it that he wanted in XIV, I'd probably go there regardless of the IP it embraces.

[Scherwiz]

I supported Tanaka, and i'll continue to support Yoshi P!

[Keith_Dragoon]

I supported Tanaka, and i'll continue to support Yoshi P!

Well put, pretty much this for me.

[Wynn]

Poor Tanaka. The scapegoat of corporate suits making decisions from afar. Spin it this way, say it that way. The sheepish masses are more than ready to tar and feather anyone the finger is pointed at when they are mad. Queue the messiah figure and voila, misdirection achieved.

Anyway, yep. I support Tanaka. Always have.

[SuzakuCMX]

Nope. Had his chance, blew it. Yoshi-P has been here for what? 6 months now? It's already much better and the battle reform looks great.

I'll give Yoshi-P his chance too and then I'll see.

[Zenaku]

Nope. Had his chance, blew it. Yoshi-P has been here for what? 6 months now? It's already much better and the battle reform looks great.

I'll give Yoshi-P his chance too and then I'll see.

Everything added right now could be Tanaka plan for all you know Tanaka was getting ready to change everything.

anyways i love tanaka back to the new MMO or ffxiv.

[SuzakuCMX]

Everything added right now could be Tanaka plan for all you know Tanaka was getting ready to change everything.

anyways i love tanaka back to the new MMO or ffxiv.

And they could be my plans. And they could be anybody's plans. Plans don't mean anything if the person can't carry through, and judging from the history of this game, Tanaka would probably make it an incredibly convoluted battle system reform.

Face the facts already. Tanaka completely and totally failed as a producer on this game and it needed a new producer. Is Yoshida the producer it needs? I don't know. We'll see, but for damn sure Tanaka did terribly as a producer on this game no matter what his plans were.