Current fix for Warrior is not using Warrior Skills?

[Tiggy]

Attack power has nothing to do with it because it works on your damage mod, not your AP mod.
Every attack in the game has a base enmity modifier, for abilities like Cure, its an enmity of 1.
For abilities such as butcher's block, its something like a 5x mod.
Your enmity is calculated according to the following as you stated earlier.

enmity mod x damage = hate created

It is correct that PLD and WAR use different bases which is why War does about the same damage as a PLD in Shield oath, BUT, you are incorrect in your assertion that a Warrior generates significantly less threat than a PLD.
In fact, a WAR using the BB>BB>SE combos is going to generate the same amount of hate if not more.
Frankly I have no idea where you got the idea that Warriors have trouble holding hate, but it is a false one.

Heck I find it too easy to take hate off Paladins in comparable gear. No way are we generating less hate.