Decrying Shield Swipe

[Brannigan]

The only problem with making Shield Swipe always worth pressing or an off-gcd ability is that it becomes a lot like Bard's Bloodletter - you can just macro it onto every step of your combo and it'll just automagically fire off. Although in that situation you'd only use it in place of Fast Blade or Savage Blade, I guess. I'd really like it if paladin got some form of actual decision making in how it uses WSes and abilities.

At this point I'd take whatever, though. The pacification is cool but so few things are actually affected by it. It also occurs to me that maybe the reason Shield Swipe isn't an amazing skill is because if gladiator was balanced around using it then they'd possibly be weak against caster mobs.

[PessimiStick]

Worthless ability. If you're running out of TP, so are the DPS, meaning a BRD will probably be using Paeon.

Except not, because DPS have Invigorate and you don't. DPS have ~17% higher TP regen than tanks.

[Lord_Zlatan]

my two cents.

Halone combo is the only current 3 ability combo that a PLD has. Riot Blade needs a 3rd WS to complete a 3 ability cycle, so I would say make shield swipe a finisher for Riot blade, but you would only be able to do it post proc, and that proc has to come during a riot blade cycle.

here is my proposal:

there are already 3 shield abilities. Start the fight off with shield lob... run in and stun, and shield swipe for +Damage, +threat.
If you proc a block in this 3 hit combo, shield swipe does AoE and Pacification. OP? maybe... Awesome? Definitly.

[Garnatian]

Except not, because DPS have Invigorate and you don't. DPS have ~17% higher TP regen than tanks.

And you have Flash which doesn't cost TP and generates perfectly reasonable threat. You should never be capped on MP and the GCDs used will easily make up for over 400 TP.

[dark494]

There's nothing wrong with shield swipe. Content that resists pacify also resists stun so I fail to see how comparing shield bash and shield swipe has any merit (but there are a few cases where things that resist stun don't resist pacify, so bonus there). It's a tp positive skill, does good damage, doesn't interrupt combo progression, with another debuff that doesn't share stun's resistance, and if you're having problems blocking (especially with a skill like Bulwark) then you have bigger issues to fix. This plus flash plus stoneskin are how good pld's mitigate their tp usage.

[KittenJitsu]

Take if off GCD

/fixed

Edit: @ Lord_Zlatan Why off GCD? Because it has requirements to cast. Aka blocking. We can't spam it unless we pull large groups or kill low levels. And it would be nice to weave it in during our combo. The dmg is not huge and will marginally increase our dmg and threat output.

[Lord_Zlatan]

Take if off GCD

/fixed

how so? how long of a CD? it can't be a skill with no cast time for only 40 TP.

Its fine ON the GCD... i like to toss it in after a savage blade and before Rage of Halone if I have FoF popped... noticeable damage increase. I just also think the potential is there, if kept ON the GCD that it can be combo'd with other shield abilities.

[Kitru]

Edit: @ Lord_Zlatan Why off GCD? Because it has requirements to cast. Aka blocking. We can't spam it unless we pull large groups or kill low levels. And it would be nice to weave it in during our combo. The dmg is not huge and will marginally increase our dmg and threat output.

Actually, the damage it deals is quite huge. It's a 210 potency attack which is higher than the average potency/GCD of the Halone combo that you're spamming all the time. Taking it off GCD without giving it a pretty big CD and/or a drastic reduction in damage would end up being a pretty massive buff to total PLD damage, especially since, with a high block rate shield, you'll be able to use it every 4-5 GCDs or pretty much every GCD if you have Bulwark up.

Taking it off GCD would necessitate, at the very least, a reduction to 50-75 potency and a CD of at least 15 seconds. Leaving it as is and just taking it off GCD would make it *insanely* strong.

Honestly, I think most PLDs would be perfectly happy to use it if it had a high enmity modifier, as previously recommended. I don't think that it needs to have an enmity mod as high as 3-3.5x (Halone combo averages 683 enmity potency per GCD, pre Shield Oath; 3-3.5x would put Shield Swipe at 630-735), mainly because I still believe that Halone *should* be what you spam to generate enmity and that higher damage/efficiency options should come at something of a cost, even if they're proc based. If Shield Swipe had even a 2x enmity modifier it would see a lot more use because the opportunity cost to your enmity generation wouldn't be as significant, which is the main reason why people use it now. At 2x enmity, you wouldn't want to use it in the opening volley because you haven't established an enmity cushion, but you'd want to use it regularly after because, while it would be a decrease in enmity generation, it wouldn't be a major decrease like it is now (at 2x, Halone combo>Shield Swipe would manage 617.7 enmity potency/GCD and 205 damage potency/GCD at the cost of 60 TP/GCD; Halone spam manages 683.3, 203.3, and 63.3; right now, Halone>Shield Swipe manages to drop your enmity potency/GCD to 565).

Honestly, Shield Swipe exists in that same weird place as Fracture does: using it is a *little* better for your damage than not using it, but not by anything approaching a noticeable amount. It's really just an ability that exists to provide the illusion of options/complexity.

[Araye]

It's a big attack, is nearly free to use, doesn't interrupt the RoH combo, I do not rely on pacification to have any effect, just as I do not expect stun to ever land (if it does great, but when I really need it, it fails)... Warriors are already crying that they can't hang, so I don't see yet one more reason to give them to cry.

There are serious issues with the game that need to be addressed. IMO, SE should focus all resources to fixing those problems and not spend one moment kowtowing to anyone crying for modifying the skill sets of any class.

For a large percentage of the FFXIV community, the game is nearly unplayable. That should be the priority.

[ShujinIhdura]

It's a nice ability in certain situations. Like.. the last boss of AK. I FoF on the pull, and once it's back up I Bulwark/FoF and spam Shield Swipe for ubar deeps.
Otherwise, I only use it on the Dullahans/Robed MRDs in AK, or in situations where I'm low on TP(T1).

I don't really think engineering hours should be burned on improving it, but I think it would be amazing if..
1. Removed from GCD.
2. Scale potency with shield block value.
3. Remove Pacify.

1 is to give it a reason to exist.
2 is to not make it OP by throwing on a low block value/high block rate shield, and it gives you slightly more of an incentive to +1 your shield or get the alla shield.
3 is because Stun > Pacify, unless a DRG in your group is DRing stun by leg sweeping in their OGCDs(like they should be).


The main thought process is for us to have something to fill OGCDs, but not make or break us in terms of threat/dps gains. It also increases the risk of being animation locked when you have to interrupt/need to react to a boss mechanic - preventing macroing it into your halone combo and increasing the skillcap on PLD.