Our attempts on Caduceus weren't even that bad if the OT didn't have to leave that night we would have eventually gotten the split part correct and killed him. Majority of the attempts that we had we wiped because of the split part where the OT wasn't able to generate and hold threat right away on boss (b) The boss (b) would immediately run towards the healer and kill them and the other party members near them due to cleave. Even during the raid the other healer (the FC master) said that the boss kept coming after him. We all didn't know why it was happening. We were all guessing after the raid that maybe the OT was just not generating enough threat. Out of all the attempts (1 out of like 4+) we did that night only one attempt where I had made a mistaken and spawned an extra add.

Even so to just give up like that and kick someone without telling them after 1 night of 4-5 attempts on a new boss for majority of us?