Unfortunate event/exerpience with <Spire>

[Aggronaught]

Even our kill on him wasn't even clean MT would loose aggro for a split second boss would run towards the ranged DPS and do his melee AoE in the middle of the room.

I don't like to get involved in the politics of a guild but to clarify, ADS' piercing laser has a minimum range, you/other tank staying at the entrance caused him to move half way across the map to cast his piercing laser, has nothing to do with aggro. You should've known this had you watched the guide that was asked to be watched before we went into coil.

EDIT: In your defense, I just looked at the logs from Saturday, and I see your HPS was higher than the other healer (around 15-20% more in coil and 2-5% more in Titan although you died every attempt on Titan to weight of the land (plumes), using FFXIVLogRep), now I don't know a lot about healing in this game or how reliable logs are(range issue, combat end time, the other healer got killed by boss aggro during splits a few times in coil etc) so take it with a grain of salt.

PS: You make some good points about the importance of being transparent with your members though which is one of the characteristic of a good guild.