Maybe I did screw up, but the first email you get for a transfer makes things very unclear. It hinted that you would be able to check status of your transfer from the service history page in account management. Since there is nothing on that page regarding a transfer at all, that's when I decided to log in. I thought that since it wasn't showing up on that page that maybe the transfer didn't work at all.

If I don't see another email for a day or so, I'll send in a ticket and see what's going on.