
That is kind of bizarre logic, and it does not tell you the damage per TP or damage per GCD. However, if you apply your logic consistently, the conclusion is still identical. Fracture deals significantly more damage per TP and significantly more damage per GCD than your main threat rotation does. It is absolutely a DPS increase to use it. However, it is a TPS (threat per second) loss. Therefore - use it when you can afford to, threatwise, and don't use it otherwise. It's exactly the same logic as shield swipe for PLD.
Sebastien has the right of it.Fracture is a dps increase but tps decrease. Should only be used when hate is not an issue (for example, medium length encounters, encounters with low aoe healing, etc). Great time for fracture is heart and post heart titan (as you'll have a massive lead by then over your healers and aoe damage actually slows down cus stomps are lessf requent). Even earlier in the fight is doable, as you'll regen tp during jumps and the like anyway.That is kind of bizarre logic, and it does not tell you the damage per TP or damage per GCD. However, if you apply your logic consistently, the conclusion is still identical. Fracture deals significantly more damage per TP and significantly more damage per GCD than your main threat rotation does. It is absolutely a DPS increase to use it. However, it is a TPS (threat per second) loss. Therefore - use it when you can afford to, threatwise, and don't use it otherwise. It's exactly the same logic as shield swipe for PLD.
Fights like turn 1 and 2, you have to move often enough, and the fights are short enough, that tp isn't a limiting factor (have to dodge lights is what I'm refering to in turn 1).
Turn 4, again you've got a lot of movement, and basically every wave is a dps check, so pretty solid reason to use fracture.
note: I'm a paladin, but the logic is the same for both classes. That said, never use fracture if you cannot ensure you will maintain threat.
It's only bizarre logic if you don't understand resource management and are ignorant of anything more than the most simplistic models and constructs. Going off of base cost while ignoring how much you regain while using it is going to give you a horribly flawed picture. Damage per TP isn't an important value; you want to look at net loss of TP per potency (which is what I've been going off of). The more something costs compared to your resource generation, the higher the opportunity cost for using it is. Overpower isn't expensive because it costs about twice as much as your single target abilities; it's expensive because it costs more than *5 times* as much in practical terms.
The first part of this is what keeps going over your head. Base cost means nothing without context. If base resource generation was 100, none of this discussion about cost would matter regardless of what damage per TP was. Damage per TP means *nothing* because Damage per TP lost per GCD is what's actually important. The second isn't actually all that true. It's true *somewhat*, but Fracture's contributions are negligible: it might deal ~80 more potency on the surface (you're almost never going to get all 10 ticks because the ticks are based off of server time, which means that, unless you hit it at *exactly* the server tick, you've got dead time on both sides) but that potency, distributed across the 13+ GCDs it would be applied over and accounting for the 2150 potency dealt over that time frame, the "benefits" of Fracture amount to a whopping 3.7% of total DPS. Factor in the buffs and everything else that Fracture doesn't benefit from or interferes with and it gets lower.Fracture deals significantly more damage per TP and significantly more damage per GCD than your main threat rotation does.
Fracture isn't worth it if you plan on fighting for longer than 2-3 minutes or less than 45-50 seconds, and even when you *do* use it, the contributions are small enough that you won't notice. The statement that it increases your DPS is semantically true and that's about it. In reality, you won't see real, practical increases to your damage *even when you use Fracture at the optimal time*. That's the entire point of this. Fracture has no real practical use for PLD *or* WAR: it costs a crapton more, decreasing your damage dealing capability over the long term, and adds so little damage that you won't even notice it.
This is silly. With that logic its almost like saying "Oh, this gear upgrade is only 1 str 1 it and 1 def/mdef. Its so miniscule i shouldnt upgrade at all cause i wont see the benefits." All in all, if you -can- increase anything viably.. Do it. Even if it's a small amount. In this case, if threat isn't an issue, use Fracture. If you're getting low on TP, halt its use. Don't just not use it because you think you'll run out too fast. Maximizing dps whenever you can is the best thing you can do, even if its "so little that you wont notice it".
P.S. No one is saying you are wrong. We're just suggesting different methods of play. There is no need to get hostile with people debating as it brings a greater knowledge to all and informs those who are too shy to ask these question.
Last edited by SofiyaGlaston; 10-23-2013 at 02:38 PM.
Alright fine it may not technically be faster using a mouse and kb setup and smashing the crap out of the button until the skill can be executed.
But using a gamepad the skills flow alot better when using OGCD skills between GCD skills and RoH is the worst for animation time leaving you with a small gap to get the next skill in without button mashing.
So there, that is why I would rather clip RoH instead of say Fastblade even if I happen to have an OGCD skill ready.

Look, you're 100% wrong, just accept it and move on.Alright fine it may not technically be faster using a mouse and kb setup and smashing the crap out of the button until the skill can be executed.
But using a gamepad the skills flow alot better when using OGCD skills between GCD skills and RoH is the worst for animation time leaving you with a small gap to get the next skill in without button mashing.
So there, that is why I would rather clip RoH instead of say Fastblade even if I happen to have an OGCD skill ready.
Maybe so, but the game does play differently on a game pad compare to mouse and kb. Clipping RoH does flow better than clipping other skills.
While the math may not hold it up 100% if a computer bot did everything, sometimes gameplay flow is more important than doing everything 100% correct.
On the original topic, yes fracture does appear to be worthless.

To bad warrior has a wasted trait in fracture (imo). I would much rather have all the class traits increase abilities that are used all the time, and not so much on situation abilities.
http://i.imgur.com/TKfbg.jpg

In an infinite TP situation where you have a threat lead, Fracture is worth using every 30 seconds. In a semi-limited TP situation, it's worth using every time Berserk is up so you only get boosted Fracture. In a very limited TP situation, it's not worth using.
There's no absolutes for those. ANY fight which you finish with more than 20 TP remaining is a fight where you could have potentially slipped in an extra fracture. Some fights have pauses for TP regeneration, some fights take longer with different group setups.
It's 100% fine to say that over long TP-starved fights, Fracture is a DPS loss due to TP starvation. But it's lazy and irresponsible to tell people to never use it, because in situations where TP isnt an issue, Fracture is the highest damage single target move a warrior has.
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.


Reply With Quote




