Time: N/A
Frequency: Trivially Reproducible
World name: N/A
Character name: N/A
NPC name: N/A
Monster name: N/A
Class/Level: N/A
Party or solo: N/A
In-game time: N/A
Area and coordinates: N/a
Steps:
1. Connect two gamepads, one after another. In my case the first controller conncted was a Razer Nostromo (controller 1), followed by a xbox 360 wireless controller (controller 2).
2. In windows gamepad settings, choose the controller that was not set as primary (controller 2), and choose to set it as the primary controller.
3. Start FFXIV. Note that the game will not respond to controller 2 even though it is set as primary. It will only respond to input from controller 1. Only after controller 1 is unplugged will FFXIV recognize input from controller 2.

Connection Specs
N/A

PC Specs
-=-=-=-=- System Information -=-=-=-=-
N/A
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-

Gamepad Manufacturer: Microsoft
Gamepad Model Name: Wireless 360 controller for windows
Gamepad Part Number: Seriously? I have no idea.

Browser Information
N/A