I think I'm at/past the point in my gear where I could tank coil with my warrior (8k hp in a party)

I'm not sure it's something I'll ever do though, even being big enough to comfortably offtank (no illusions that I'd be big enough to handle the 4 stack dreadnought or the double dreadnought after) it just doesn't seem like it's worth it

My group makes use of the fact that scholar DoTs tick harder than summoner DoTs - effectively our dps is higher because we use two paladins that require less healing than warriors would

I just can't rationalize bringing an inferior class to the raid, first world min-maxer problems I guess.