MVP and Vote Kick.. Try to break it!

[OrganizationXIll]

This is what I think should be the rules and will be "solutions" for your cons for the kick function.

1) You have to have 75% of the votes. If its a four man dungeon it has to be unanimous; in an eight man, 6 out of the 8 are required.
2) New players cannot be kicked no matter what. Their name doesn't appear in the kick list.
3) You only get 3 kicks a day. That way it limits what the elitist will vote for.
4) If you get kicked you are warned. Twice in a day you are locked for 15 minutes. Three times an hour. On the fourth time you are locked out until a set time per region. (EX: 8:00 am PST)
5) If you kick someone you have the option to leave a highly censored message 25 characters or less that are visible on the Duty Finder screen of the kicked player until a check box is marked. Any locked out time (see above) doesn't start until this check box is checked.

EDIT:

@OrganizationXIll: another time a first timer fall with a group of elitist jerk that kick him out of the dungeon because he want to see him CS, with no luck him second group is the same, with no luck the poor soul fall again with a group like this for the third and fourth time... he get lock simply for trying to enjoy the game.

i think the concern they have are about this. the tool in itself is not bad, but how the people will use it can lead to some huge trouble.

How many times do you really think they will have 6 or more when they don't have 8? Probably a quarter of the time if that. The fact is if they are elitist enough to have 6 they will probably have 2 more friends. If not then they probably wont have the 75% they need. Also, all the while this guy you are referring to would be the worlds most unlucky guy to get in those groups twice let alone 4 times. It will happen twice in a row very rarely, but beyond that? If they aren't doing anything wrong then the majority of the community will just leave them be since they plan on running the dungeon another 10ish times more to get the cap of 300. They wont want to waste one of their 3 votes on a guy that is legitimately trying to do the dungeon and is just bad. They will want to save them for trolls.