Quote Originally Posted by Ninjiitstu View Post
Your math is wrong. Brutal Swing is Off Cooldown for War, but not taken into account. Additionally, it's in a vacuum that doesn't exist in practical application. Spirits within is a Silence that builds DR. It is not part of any reasonably person's rotation on anything other then trash mobs, which should not be a realistic view on DPS.

That being said, PLD still does more more damage then a WAR on single target. WAR is much more effective against Multiple targets. I imagine if anything were to change with these two tanks, this would be the first thing.
You can spam Spirits Within on the vast majority of mobs in the game with no issue.