Quote Originally Posted by Kitru View Post
No, we don't. A properly played PLD in Sword Oath will do more damage than a WAR outside of Defiance. Just check the math (link in sig).
Your math is wrong. Brutal Swing is Off Cooldown for War, but not taken into account. Additionally, it's in a vacuum that doesn't exist in practical application. Spirits within is a Silence that builds DR. It is not part of any reasonably person's rotation on anything other then trash mobs, which should not be a realistic view on DPS.

That being said, PLD still does more more damage then a WAR on single target. WAR is much more effective against Multiple targets. I imagine if anything were to change with these two tanks, this would be the first thing.