Duty Finder Kick Vote

I would like to petition the addition of a kicking system to Duty Finder; perhaps a kick vote, meaning if seven of the party vote to kick somebody then they are kicked from Duty and also suffer the 15 minute wait.

I am tired of people joining a Duty Finder group, something going wrong, bitching and then spending the rest of their time in that group wiping on purpose, screwing up, generally ruining other people's gameplay. They don't drop because they don't want to wait 15 minutes, meaning somebody else, who isn't being a magnificent so-in-so, has to take the 15 minute hit.

In my opinion, this is quite disgusting.

Some will say it will be abused; the thing is I perceive all seven members voting somebody out for no reason to happen much less than somebody doing what I described above.

So please, SE, add a kick vote to Duty Finder so we don't have to put up with these cretins anymore.

Well making someone suffer 15min for being kicked is a bit whack. But adding a button to kick someone with a vote is great. But being kicked and suffering 15min would suck if people teamed up and just kicked people for fun or other reasons

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tbo

Well making someone suffer 15min for being kicked is a bit whack. But adding a button to kick someone with a vote is great. But being kicked and suffering 15min would suck if people teamed up and just kicked people for fun or other reasons

---

The 1000 word limit is silly, so I couldn't elaborate too much, but yeah. This is my only real concern. I'm sure it will be abused and that will suck for anyone on the receiving end. Perhaps there could be other requirements based on tell tale behaviour. In one run a moment ago the Black Mage didn't do any nuking; a Black Mage not nuking is clearly not being a Black Mage.

Perhaps if certain criteria are met once people have voted, they get kicked. I don't know.

I still think the circumstances of a random group of seven people randomly kicking somebody (considering most people in DF are nice, intelligent people) would be very low; whereas I have had people intentionally ruining runs several times now.

I'm against it. It will be abused for sure.
I prefer to leave the group and suffer a 15 minutes debuff, which isn't that much.

A group of three friends decided to make a party and apply for four men instance via Duty finder.
At the end of the battle, one of them want the loot from the chest so they kick vote player "A".
Player "A" got kicked out the party and suffer for 15 minutes wait.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cairn

A group of three friends decided to make a party and apply for four men instance via Duty finder.
At the end of the battle, one of them want the loot from the chest so they kick vote player "A".
Player "A" got kicked out the party and suffer for 15 minutes wait.

---

"Error: Player can not be kicked when loot is in pool."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ReplicaX

"Error: Player can not be kicked when loot is in pool."

---

Okay, before they open the chest...

So someones gets together 7 like minded jerks together. Once the prize is won they kick the 8th to ensure their team gets the drop.

Why is it that people are very against the potential to group up and kick someone, but are perfectly fine with people sitting in a run not participating or ruining the run because they want to abuse it to soulbind gear. Why is one not fair but the other is?

I support this completely, had enough of dealing with people sitting their in my runs not doing anything.

No. Potential for abuse and trolling is way too high.

I could definitely have used this feature in a dungeon last night. The counterpoint is that this type of system has bred some pretty contemptible behavior in other games.

It would be beyond awful for any dps.

Think of this, party wipes, immediately the lowest geared dps will get blamed.

Noone will blame the tank, they're too afraid and the tank can just instaqueue again.
Same for the healer.
The other dps will immediately get on the bandwagon so they don't kick her instead.

Bam, you're out, enjoy your 1 hour queue.

And it might not even be a gear issue. Maybe its your first time there, and people are jerks, as you no doubt know in games, ANYTHING that is inconvenient for even the slightest reason will tick them off.

Maybe it was your fault that you wiped the group, but maybe thats because they rushed, or it was your first time there.

Certainly the kick is unwarranted.

Kick feature? YES PLEASE!

Nothing like getting legacy players who don't know their own characters.

Or better yet, same legacy players who have several level 50 classes rolling on level 35 gear......../facepalm
The argument that they can use it for another class they have not leveled wasn't applicable, they had all the required classes to 50. (Trolololol) /sadface

Tie Kick feature in with a check box to specifically NOT group with legacies and I think a great many people would be happy to warrant the additions. Just add another check box like the "Join active party" box.

As for the whole loot thing...add a mechanic that makes it so you cant kick DURING and several minutes AFTER a BOSS fight as well as when loot is currently being rolled on. PROBLEM SOLVED! /WIN /WIN /WIN

This needs to happen.

I just got out of a Cutter's Cry run with a self-described "Thunder Mage" - meaning he spammed Thunder II 95% of the time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FinagleABagel

No. Potential for abuse and trolling is way too high.

---

unlike the trolling that is happening now?
3/4ths of primal HM runs have resulted in one person either after the first wipe or often before even the first attempt someone decides the group will never make it so they refuse to play (sometimes afking other times talking crap the entire time). Regardless, the rest of the group often is now stuck, and one of those who actually tried to do the raid now has to leave and suffer the 15m debuff and the jerk gets away free.

but thats okay because some people might abuse the system. isnt that kind of like all prisons should be abolished because some people are innocently accused?

simple fix have when stating,15 min timer before you can vote to kick some one most fight will take at least that long until you know they are bad and have a 1 min timer after a battle fight before you can kick some one.