Summoner Carbuncle

Why is this still a thing? All it does is get in the way and make things clunky, you die and you need to resummon, want to use an aegis... too bad you're in one of your summon phases. All it is used for is to make things more annoying than they need to be.

We all know they aren't going to do anything with Carbuncle so let's just get rid of it, if you DO want to keep it then let it jump out when you use aegis and maybe physick if they decide what to do with that ... maybe resurrection if they decide to keep it.

I mean its true. but SC is way to scared to remove stuff.
And i can tell you some people will be pretty angry when they remove it.

I feel that they could separate Radiant Aegis from the carbuncle and let it just be an optional cosmetic feature for SMNs.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Unyqua

I mean its true. but SC is way to scared to remove stuff.
And i can tell you some people will be pretty angry when they remove it.

---

It didnt stop them from removing the entire job to replace it with 2 buttons. Take the rat out behind the shed, whats one more mechanic thrown in the bin for the sake of their terrible demi idea.

what confused me why we need carbuncle to summon the other? cant we just summon them normally? or i miss the part in the story lore where the carbuncle is some sort of catalyst to use in summoning

if i sprint, my summon got left behind and sometime it take a seconds before i can summon my bahamut or others

and off course the obvious one is when you summon others you cant use your defensive ability because it required you to have your summon in carbuncle state

Carbuncle is just leftovers from when they actually did something but if they are just going to stand there and get in the way then we are better off just getting rid of them. Yes I like the little bugger but I also like my skills to work when I want them to.

carbuncle should just be a summon as well that puts a shell on the whole party like in FF6

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by anna-steele

carbuncle should just be a summon as well that puts a shell on the whole party like in FF6

---

Which he does, the defense ability from smn that require carbuncle is sort of like that, it just personal defense not party wide

The problem is why it stay "outside"? The other summon went away after they do their job but the little bugger just stay with us the entire time instead off bail out like tataru carbuncle lol

well yeah thats what i mean, it should be the whole party not just self then if we are going to be the worst damage.

A remnant that for some reason still gets pushed forward, like fkin necrotize.

I'd rather it be auto summoned after ressing alongside you, and make the carbuncle have egi assaults again myself

They got to make it so that the lvl 90+ summons retain the carbuncle form <.<

And carbuncle options for bahamut/phoenix!

auto summon is nice, but if they doesn't do it, atleast make summon carbuncle and fairy become instant cast just like tank stance, especially fairy, SCH being punished harder than SMN, because alot of their healing ability depend on fairy, while other healer can immediately return to healing when they get res, SCH need to resummon fairy for job to function

Forgot about fairy since I don't heal too much but yeah that is a problem, thing is they have to pretty much have to overhaul carbuncle to make it worth keeping while they actually designed the job around the fairy. They could make it a passive skill rather than a casted one.

I don't want to see carbuncle removed completely, but it would be nice if it respawned with you after death. It would also be nice if aegis was buffed so that it doesn't require carbuncle specifically.

Carbuncle is the last thing that connects me to what was once my favorite job so sure, remove it and the final vestiges of my desire to play this game.

If they don't free him from the other summons and actually give him something to do, as far as I'm concerned it's just a boring thing to have to do every wipe.

easy way is to make it work like tank stance, tank stance is not perfect, but atleast it's less annoying than have to resummon everytime

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Unyqua

I mean its true. but SC is way to scared to remove stuff SE correctly anticipates the berserk howling outrage that would ensue were carbuncle removed, even though people complain about carbuncle constantly.

---

Fixed that for you :cool: As you later explain:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Unyqua

And i can tell you some people will be pretty angry when they remove it.

---

just saw patch note, thats it for summoner? i mean a buff is a buff