(Spoilers) The bird that made me quit MSQ permanently

We meet a sentient, intelligent bird who is not threatening us in any way, and the party decides to just thoughtlessly kill it like some trophy prize to eat…the only reason given that it might have been inconveniencing some researchers.

Then hypocritically, the hunters talk at dinner about their love of peace, and their disgust with the Garlean’s desire to bend the world to their will.

Of course the hrothgar hunter doesn’t kill and eat her viera bunny friend, valuing only amorphous individuals and happy to subjugate all others.

After some really progressive story like Elpis, I can’t help but just be very disappointed. What’s next, will we cook Alpha for dinner?

This just highlights basically everything that’s horrible about humanity.

all life is built on the backs of other life, as we speak you digest millions of bacteria in your gut, you monster.

Alpha do look delicious

Considering a sentinent bird was responsible for everything that is wrong with the universe and caused the Final Days, I think we're fully justified to fry up some roast chicken.

It was a parrot repeating things. Not a sapient being.

How do you define sentient? It was a big parrot mimicking sounds it had heard. I can't recall anyone ever considering parrots "sentient". I know they are considered the most intelligent birds but sentient is a different thing.

It was clearly an invasive species to the area disrupting the native wildlife. What is the general approach to dealing with invasive species that are predators? Kill it so the native wildlife continues to prosper in its habitat.

Didn't you notice the somewhat uncomfortable expressions on the faces of the Scions at the mention of getting to know Wuk via a hunt? Something that would be very natural to the real life predators that the Hrothgar are modeled after?

Didn't you notice that the Scions only agreed to that hunt because of the requests from the researchers to discover what was upsetting the native wildlife?

Sure, humanity is still messed up in a lot of ways but it feels like you're going out of your way to find reasons to be angry about what has happened in a fictional story. If that's the breaking point for you and the MSQ, it sounds like you've already been trying to come up with reasons to quit.

You've had the game since 2014 and most certainly killed hundreds of thousands npcs of all sorts...and you suddenly worry about a single pixel parrot?

Permanently you say? hmmm idk about that. You'll be back for Dawntrail lol Thanks for playing and hope you find another game to play .

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jojoya

How do you define sentient? It was a big parrot mimicking sounds it had heard. I can't recall anyone ever considering parrots "sentient". I know they are considered the most intelligent birds but sentient is a different thing.

---

You're confusing sentient with intelligent.
Almost all the things we kill in the game are sentient in some capacity. The robots perhaps not.
Even the wild beasts the roam the land are likely able to conceive of joy and sorrow. They can think for themselves and do what they want. They are by the very definition: sentient.

What they are not is intelligent. Smart and clever, surely. But higher level functions of communication and thought formulation and realizing the abstract, etc., that's the gift of us spoken. And the best tribes too!

The bird is fair game as far as I'm concerned.

I think its safe to say we all committed mass genocide
Garleans,
Kobalds,
Sahaghins,
Church cult of Ishgard
Dragons
List goes on but you get the idea. At this point I'd kill just about anything who gives me the wrong look

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Canadane

You're confusing sentient with intelligent.

---

Actually, I was probably thinking sapient when I wrote that.

And the bird was damn tasty too.

This is where you draw the line ?? Rly?? After all the WoL did lol. Maye animal crossing will fit better to your delicate soul?

That PS3 meat looked disgustingly raw and unseasoned anyway.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Komoritane

After some really progressive story like Elpis

---

Uh...after meeting the people of Elpis we ate their entire species. So...

My bigger issue with eating the bird is if we killed it cause it was making the other animals crazy was no one concerned that eating it would make us go crazy too?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VictorSpoils

That PS3 meat looked disgustingly raw and unseasoned anyway.

---

And alarmingly like lamb chops for something that allegedly came from a bird.

I'm not sure if I'm more concerned by that or by the fact that we killed something possibly unknown to science and then all that anyone can think of is eating it.