Is it his fault that he got mass reported?

https://i.imgur.com/41dqYeC.png

this email is not mine
basically because someone got mass reported maliciously does that mean they are at fault?
why does the email threaten the person being reported, despite them not having broken a single rule in the ToS?

Hesitant as I am to say it, I do feel that more context is needed here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

https://i.imgur.com/41dqYeC.png

this email is not mine
basically because someone got mass reported maliciously does that mean they are at fault?
why does the email threaten the person being reported, despite them not having broken a single rule in the ToS?

---

Looks fake, the GMs start with a warning typically and don't contact you for shit like this

Sounds like he was purposely being annoying/trolly and got reported by a ton of people. Also, it looks like simply a warning, "stop being annoying".

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

https://i.imgur.com/41dqYeC.png

this email is not mine
basically because someone got mass reported maliciously does that mean they are at fault?
why does the email threaten the person being reported, despite them not having broken a single rule in the ToS?

---

Eh no action was taken might be a boiler plate SOP thing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Carin-Eri

Hesitant as I am to say it, I do feel that more context is needed here.

---

Why are you hesitant about that? Because that's exactly what needs to be said.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mosha

Eh no action was taken might be a boiler plate SOP thing.

---

Lol if that is boiler plate they need to fire the person who wrote this because it's so unprofessional. Like "Duty Contents"

My guess is fake.

Ask for a screenshot of the the full email, inc., the sender. Seems sus otherwise.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EderTheBro

Lol if that is boiler plate they need to fire the person who wrote this because it's so unprofessional. Like "Duty Contents"

---

Let's be real "Duty contents" is just them opening a drop-down and selecting it from a list

"We've received significant amount of reports, we didn't bother checking whether they're justified or not, but either way, pls be nice."

It's either fake, or whatever authority sent that is just borderline incompetent.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EderTheBro

Looks fake, the GMs start with a warning typically and don't contact you for shit like this

---

Wow cant believe you dont trust known liar seiyasoiya when they post something, really messed up from you. /s

Blizzard has done the same thing in the past, so I wouldn't be surprised if SE does something similar. Someone on server being a general nuisance but skating close enough to the TOS to not actually break them.

That said, this email just looks...fake.

That's not even a caution. It's probably a boiler plate email they send to a player, if one has multiple reports sent against them. It doesn't actually have any consequences, if the player did nothing wrong.

It's hard to say whose fault it is without knowing the context. Innocent person who hasn't spoken to anyone but a streamer didn't like them? Not at fault. A-hole getting mass reported? Their own fault. The next time they do actually break the ToS they're gone.

Sorry but that doesn't seem real. I doubt they would contact you just to say "Hey people have been reporting you but you technically aren't doing anything wrong. Just so you know." They either act or do not act against you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Renalt

Sorry but that doesn't seem real. I doubt they would contact you just to say "Hey people have been reporting you but you technically aren't doing anything wrong. Just so you know." They either act or do not act against you.

---

Yeah...kind of Off....doesnt look or feel like the kind of Email you'd get...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

because someone got mass reported maliciously does that mean they are at fault?

---

This line of Dialogue is also Pretty Sus.....How do you know Somebody was Maliciously Mass Reported?
Also, why are you sharing someone else's Email?
I doubt this is the Full Email To, as it lacks some information. They would Specify what was said, and what was reported. They wouldn't just send a Broad Email like this.

I would know, Ive been Suspended 2 times.
Once for getting a lil Heated and using Offensive Language. And the 2nd time was complete Nonsense that makes me lose some Faith in these MODs (Not saying what it is for protection) And both times the Emails stated Why I was reported and suspended, along with a Link and a Quote of what was said, and where it Violates the Rules.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Deo14

"We've received significant amount of reports, we didn't bother checking whether they're justified or not, but either way, pls be nice."

It's either fake, or whatever authority sent that is just borderline incompetent.

---

Yeah, I was about to say. This GM team is seriously dropping the ball.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zanarkand-Ronso

Yeah...kind of Off....doesnt look or feel like the kind of Email you'd get...



This line of Dialogue is also Pretty Sus.....How do you know Somebody was Maliciously Mass Reported?
Also, why are you sharing someone else's Email?
I doubt this is the Full Email To, as it lacks some information. They would Specify what was said, and what was reported. They wouldn't just send a Broad Email like this.

I would know, Ive been Suspended 2 times.
Once for getting a lil Heated and using Offensive Language. And the 2nd time was complete Nonsense that makes me lose some Faith in these MODs (Not saying what it is for protection) And both times the Emails stated Why I was reported and suspended, along with a Link and a Quote of what was said, and where it Violates the Rules.

---

This is from a player in the CCRC official tournament that nobody here even seems to know about
this player was from one of the particularly hated teams

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zanarkand-Ronso

Yeah...kind of Off....doesnt look or feel like the kind of Email you'd get...



This line of Dialogue is also Pretty Sus.....How do you know Somebody was Maliciously Mass Reported?
Also, why are you sharing someone else's Email?
I doubt this is the Full Email To, as it lacks some information. They would Specify what was said, and what was reported. They wouldn't just send a Broad Email like this.

I would know, Ive been Suspended 2 times.
Once for getting a lil Heated and using Offensive Language. And the 2nd time was complete Nonsense that makes me lose some Faith in these MODs (Not saying what it is for protection) And both times the Emails stated Why I was reported and suspended, along with a Link and a Quote of what was said, and where it Violates the Rules.

---

Hold up, Square absolutely will not say what you got reported for. They'll say "harassment" or some other vague response but they do not say what it was that actually landed you in GM gaol. It's one of the biggest complaints people have about this game's justice system.

That they actually gave you examples is... well I don't think you're lying but it's also hard to believe, especially as I landed myself in GM gaol once and they would not tell me what I said that was so bad (I'm pretty sure it was a stupid lewd joke I made during a hunt train though, nothing else makes sense).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

This is from a player in the CCRC official tournament that nobody here even seems to know about
this player was from one of the particularly hated teams

---

so, pvp happened, during a tournament... and your "friend" apparently was most egregious and was reported by many because the "team" was hated?

I am guessing your "friend" was a darling angel and did never and would never indulge in typical behaviour that occurs in pvp?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kes13a

so, pvp happened, during a tournament... and your "friend" apparently was most egregious and was reported by many because the "team" was hated?

I am guessing your "friend" was a darling angel and did never and would never indulge in typical behaviour that occurs in pvp?

---

that's not the point, the GMs admitted that he hasn't broken any rule in the ToS
according to these forums the ToS are perfect and infallible, so it should cover any bad behavior regardless of what it is

I'm hesitant to believe the initial post because from what i've observed the GMs just toss you into mordion gaol and when one of them is both online and free -then- they give you your warning.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

This is from a player in the CCRC official tournament that nobody here even seems to know about
this player was from one of the particularly hated teams

---

Bro only 4chan neckbeards pays attention to that drama

Even t100 feasters don't give a shit

Also I just asked around including some t10s, outside of people in CCRC legitimately no one even cares. Kinda funny to see a random 4chan anon try to lord over t100s about being "in the know".

Basically this:

https://i.ibb.co/bPLy9S8/IMG-1049.jpg

Even Zodiark trancers drama was more spicy lmao

#makefeastgreatagain

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

that's not the point, the GMs admitted that he hasn't broken any rule in the ToS
according to these forums the ToS are perfect and infallible, so it should cover any bad behavior regardless of what it is

---

Right, but they just informed him that a mass report happened and they chose to take no action.
in his ffxiv record, he is still the perfect angel if he has no warning againsts his account

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Denji

I'm hesitant to believe the initial post because from what i've observed the GMs just toss you into mordion gaol and when one of them is both online and free -then- they give you your warning.

---

Really?! For how long?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Carin-Eri

Really?! For how long?

---

Depends on what you did and they'll keep you there if its a temporary suspension. Once you've "served your time" you have to then wait for one of them to both be online/on the clock and ready/willing to release you iirc. It isn't terribly long but the length of time can vary a little bit if they're off doing something else.

Honestly I like it over an automated system since if you've done something bad enough to warrant being placed in gay baby jail GM prison then you should be made to wait for when a GM is free to release you.

It's also used for disputes where they need more information such as an argument between two players.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

https://i.imgur.com/41dqYeC.png

this email is not mine
basically because someone got mass reported maliciously does that mean they are at fault?
why does the email threaten the person being reported, despite them not having broken a single rule in the ToS?

---

So this can lead to a TOS violation is why they mention it.
"Nuisance behavior" is one of those things you can be reported for that are really case by case. Essentially if someone else was hurt by your actions, you can be actioned. Regardless if it was against TOS or not.
The grey area in that one is kinda dumb, but that's probably why.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zebraoracle

Hold up, Square absolutely will not say what you got reported for. They'll say "harassment" or some other vague response but they do not say what it was that actually landed you in GM gaol. It's one of the biggest complaints people have about this game's justice system.

That they actually gave you examples is... well I don't think you're lying but it's also hard to believe, especially as I landed myself in GM gaol once and they would not tell me what I said that was so bad (I'm pretty sure it was a stupid lewd joke I made during a hunt train though, nothing else makes sense).

---

I never got sent to Gaol (Jail) it was just a Suspension from the Forums. And they did specify why.
Maybe its different In-Game then it is on the Forums. That or there are Different Mods who Operate Differently altogether. Very Possible.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zanarkand-Ronso

I never got sent to Gaol (Jail) it was just a Suspension from the Forums. And they did specify why.
Maybe its different In-Game then it is on the Forums. That or there are Different Mods who Operate Differently altogether. Very Possible.

---

They actually moderate this place?
Incredible.

You wont get a mail or warning like that, if you did not do anything wrong...

My verdict is you don't just get reported out in the open sky and that they do take their time to read things when they issue a warning or perform a ban.

Some people are trolling, and on purpose trying to get on peoples nerves, it may not actually be breaking the ToS and the likes, but if you mess people too much up, you are just going to get the short end of the stick and that is that.

No sympathy for the person, some people just exist to openly annoy others and then complain, when the GMs or moderators tell you to stop, stop yourself would be the better answer and solution to things.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Denji

They actually moderate this place?
Incredible.

---

Not really. You kinda have to moderate it yourself. With the proper tools it works to great effect.

This makes no sense. No GM would acknowledge that the system was being abused. They would either throw you in the gaol or they wouldn't.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

that's not the point, the GMs admitted that he hasn't broken any rule in the ToS
according to these forums the ToS are perfect and infallible, so it should cover any bad behavior regardless of what it is

---

Ah, I knew there was some sort of "gotcha" with this thread, there *always* is with you. It all makes sense now. Nothing more to see here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zanarkand-Ronso

I never got sent to Gaol (Jail) it was just a Suspension from the Forums. And they did specify why.
Maybe its different In-Game then it is on the Forums. That or there are Different Mods who Operate Differently altogether. Very Possible.

---

Oh I thought you meant in game. That makes more sense.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Denji

They actually moderate this place?
Incredible.

---

They only bother to look if something gets enough reports. And even then, they tend to either ignore it, or nuke the whole thread. It's rare to see anything in between.

Looks fake I don't see the GM's name below it that sent it.

Just from OP itself, it's already a fake :)

Go back to 4chan and try again.

Its 100% fake.

No GM name, no formatting that we would normally see with a GM response, the entire thing has the veracity of a three dollar bill.

Disregard, ignore, move on.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SeiyaSoiya

https://i.imgur.com/41dqYeC.png

this email is not mine
basically because someone got mass reported maliciously does that mean they are at fault?
why does the email threaten the person being reported, despite them not having broken a single rule in the ToS?

---

and i fell for this sweet jesus.