What if players could create dungeons in-game?

It could be like a mix of PoTD/HOH, and housing.

Gatherers and crafters could provide stuff for the dungeon like with housing. Crafters could e.g. create traps like in Halatali (Hard) or as seen in some of the Stormblood dungeons along with other interior. If a version of beastmaster is added at some point, one could place specific monsters/bosses in the dungeon if monster taming is something they could do, similar to FSH and aquariums.

Sizes
The sizes of the dungeon could be 1-5 floors? Maybe one could expand it from 1-2 floors and up? One could set up a biggish room area like in HOH and in trials, or several small with monsters, traps, puzzles, and boss(es).

Interior and enemy settings
The creator(s) could set and lock key terms to alter the dungeon floor(s) like with the Arcane Labyrinth in Final Fantasy II Anniversary Edition, and with that also set status effects like with POTD/HOH. Maybe one could place puzzles and set underwater movement in some of the areas/floors, along with furniture and interior pieces from the housing system. Setting i-/levels syncing could be done? Running through it with squad members or Trusts for testing could also be something to consider but would probably be too much work for the AI development team.

Roleplay
Roleplayers and FCs could customize and organize small dungeon crawls and events. With the world visit system one could arrange a larger cross-world customized dungeon crawl. For annual events like Halloween/All Saint's Wake, maybe a FC would like to create their own similar events.

PVP
Would that be something one would want to be able to toggle on/off in the player created dungeon? While still having monsters?

Rewards
The owner(s) of the dungeon could place a reward in a treasure chest if they wanted, like a cookie, or some other tradeable item or equipment piece. Maybe one could place a retainer at the entrance to resupply the treasure chest and greet challengers. The reward left by the creator(s) should then be visible? The rewards could also be something like with guildhests or levequests. In exchange, the owner of the dungeon could have the retainer collect fragments/other (untradeable?) items that "drop" in the dungeon. People challenging the dungeon could leave a guest book message or like if they wanted. Any other suggestions?

RMT and bots
A bit unsure but maybe have no XP and gil earning so bots can't use it for leveling or suck up the rewards? Having a gil fee traded to the retainer to challenge the dungeon could be a bit troublesome if that was a transfer. Same with having gil rewards. Though the gil fee could be a sink for dungeon maintenance, like with aetherytes and taxes? Maybe paying in GC seals, tomestones, leves, or some other token would be better?

Access
Where in the game world could it be added? Whether or not the entrances would be instanced I'm unsure about as well, but given the housing situation it probably should.

The dungeon itself would probably at least be public entry, and with setting a retainer one would have an in-game explanation with the option to set it private, friends, FC, and exclude blacklisted characters. Private keywords would be unnecessary if it's not instanced, and could be spread (people also may forget them). Private keys like in Bloodborne chalice dungeons would also be unnecessary as the dungeon would be player created. Player search is feasible if instanced and you don't remember (could have a note about "last visited dd/mm/yy" in the margin)

Duly noted
Something like this probably wouldn't be able to be added until at least 6.0, people are clamoring for housing space and wards regularly, would most likely use significant developer resources, and be separate from housing.

What do you think about something like player-created dungeons? If you wanted, you could make something akin to Newt Scamanders creature space in Fantastic Beast and Where to Find Them.

It's obviously not impossible, but it sounds very resouce-intensive. Not just development resources, but server capacity too. One of the reasons the housing situation is so abysmal is due to the server strain all these custom plots exert. They'd probably have to make some major (and costly) infrastructure upgrades to even try something like this.

I won't say there wouldn't be some creative designs, but with a platform like XIV I don't know that players could actually produce meaningfully different or interesting content.

Could be funny, actually. Just leave out Aurum Vale hazards and mechanics and I'm peachy.

It would be wonderful. Maybe would could get dungeons with more interesting mechanics and interaction than...

pull to gate > pull to boss > boss > pull to gate > pull to boss > boss > pull to gate > pull to boss > boss

or in the case of 24 mans

trash > boss > trash > boss > trash > boss

Anything outside of the highest tier content that you had to actually focus on instead of watch Netflix while you half heartedly press buttons would be a breath of fresh air.

I remember once playing an old MMO that had this. It also had a rating system so players could find the best dungeons. The dialogue some of the better creators wrote was hilarious and overall, it definitely broke up the monotony of dungeon grinding.

The idea is really neat sort of like a workshop, and would be great to see stuff that players have pout time into doing so that others can enjoy it!
But it feels it would be abused to an extent.

this isn't that type of game. plus everyone would just make aurum vale savage.

This is a great idea. Dungeons and Dragons Online had the same thing. It's a lot of fun.

Final Fantasy flavored Tomb Of Horrors.

Have fun.

BLACK HOLE IN THE STATUE'S MOUTH! Eat one million damage for falling for the schuck bait.

Isn't this just a Lalafel's basement?

9 million entries of dungeon of the genitals, or mario/zelda rip offs that would have to be constantly removed for copyright violations.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by griffinborn

Could be funny, actually. Just leave out Aurum Vale hazards and mechanics and I'm peachy.

---

The first thing that came to mind was trying to re-create 1.0's version of The Aurum Vale.

I would make one huge maze with random monsters at dead ends and have traps in it. Maybe have few pit traps in it.

I will be completely honest I did not read your entire thread you had me at the title. I completely and wholeheartedly agree that would be an awesome thing to do it would definitely create player and fan interest and probably flood new life into our servers. Personally I believe if they could pull that off FFXIV would no longer be the number 2 MMORPG. If FFXIV could pull that off I believe that would be enough to push this great MMORPG to the number one spot. After all with all of the player housing the community has shown Final Fantasy XIV that it definitely wants more control than it currently has and by allowing players to create Dungeons and pick which bosses and mobs were in that dungeon at which points it would make the game a lot more enjoyable and a lot of people would be in Duty Finder to either A. create the dungeon themselves or B. to check out the wonderful designs people have made.

Thank you for the awesome idea