Scholar priority stats

Hello guys, im now i314 and idk the best materia use to my stuff, now priority Stats is crit or deter ? And secondary always speed cast ?

There's a previous thread about healer melds right under yours: http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...put-in-my-gear

For scholars crit is usually a given for those crit adlos. Been that way since 2.0

Beyond that guessing it is a combo of piety and det

Why the hell would you meld piety ? The gear gives us way enough of it already. Go for Direct hit so you can maximize your dps, or Det if you're not totally sure about DH

Honestly with the increased cost of adlo and the decreased potency of critical hits, compiled with the loss of fairy crits giving us a buff to spspd we may need to reevaluate whats bis for scholar its not like were fishing for critlos anymore sure its still probably best just due to the nature of the stat but its definitely lost a lot of the draw it once had.

Adlo and succor weren't skills that we were supposed to spam anyway. Also you do have a co healer. You just won't help him as much asbefore, because of this insane cost ( i agree this wasn't justified), but instead you'll focus on dps and situational help ( exco, fairy...).
And piety materias won't help you spam Adlo anyway.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Llynd

Adlo and succor weren't skills that we were supposed to spam anyway. Also you do have a co healer. You just won't help him as much asbefore, because of this insane cost ( i agree this wasn't justified), but instead you'll focus on dps and situational help ( exco, fairy...).
And piety materias won't help you spam Adlo anyway.

---

But they will help maintain through the raising while learning content.

Well, if you're fine with scholar being a 2nd rate healer, thats your business. But I prefer to main heal with it, as it is, you know, a healer job. And it used to be quite possible. Sure, some fights were a little harder than others, depending on aoe healing requirements, but careful use of eye4eye, sacred soil, and fey covenant, and good timing on whispering dawn, made it possible to fill that role. (even to solo heal A12s, which required a significant amount of group healing). As it is now, that is not even possible.

The key design change was that scholar was the least efficient healer, but that was offset by having superior mp recovery. Now, we have even less efficient heals, and even worse mp recovery. This is while both whm and ast saw increases in their ability to heal, and more importantly, mitigate incoming damage. Now its at the point where the potential healing of astro and whm is about twice that of scholar, and the mitigation tools that sch does have, don't even come close to making up that difference. I honestly don't think SE has anyone that plays scholar, they just had a brainstorming session to come up with ways to nerf it, and they came up with a dozen suggestions, and implemented all of them, without any consideration of how they would multiplicatively affect each other.

tldr> sch healing is broken, and needs an emergency fix. unfortunately, SE wont notice until people stop playing it.

Prioritize Crit and Det. We always need the Crit due to shields, and we need the Det to bring up our healing. Looking at the current i320 Omega gear, we're going to need a lot of Savage Might VI to bring up the Det, because the gear is mostly providing Crit, SS, and Piety. It's bad enough to where doing the math, our DET will be under 1K, not a good place for it to be at.

Ok thanks you ! Because for the moment i maximize crit but i dont see the difference in fight :/

i'd say crit and spell speed. spell speed was the best stat for scholar in 3.5, but people took crit over it because of adlo. det might be better on the first tier of savage but ss is eventually going to win, given how it has incrementing returns

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Llynd

Why the hell would you meld piety ? The gear gives us way enough of it already. Go for Direct hit so you can maximize your dps, or Det if you're not totally sure about DH

---

Healers can't direct hit though...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by xNewbx

Healers can't direct hit though...

---

heals cant direct, but attack spells can. i can see dh melds being good but we'd need substat weight data to see if 13 melds of direct hit is worth it though

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by QooEr

heals cant direct, but attack spells can. i can see dh melds being good but we'd need substat weight data to see if 13 melds of direct hit is worth it though

---

Hm you're right. I always thought you couldn't because I never have, but looking into it, the base DHR of 364 means you have a 0% to direct hit. You could meld 720 DH giving you 1,084 DH. Would be curious how good that would be compared to melding DET which would benefit heals and attacks. Or let alone Crit. I was able to put Crit on most of my gear. I actually want to put some DH in at least one piece because I bet having some % chance to DH is better than none.