Fisher off-hand suggestion: Tackle-box.

ok, so the fisher DoL is taking a lot of inventory space. i could sell most of my bait, but the problem is that some fishing spots have fish that require a mooch, forcing me to keep low level bait in order to mooch a low level fish.

its not like we dedicate a large amount of inventory space for other DoL classes, so it is rather odd for the fisher to be the only one of the classes that has to dedicate inventory space for both it's tools (bait) and resources acquired.

so here is the suggestion: a tackle-box off hand for the fisher. extra inventory space exclusive to bait and bait alone. there could be different varieties of tackle boxes that would have more inventory space depending on the tackle-box's level.

to add, i dont know if it would be too much to give each tackle-box a model and place it beside players while fishing.

good or bad idea?

Its not only a good idea, but it is probably THE most requested DoL feature since 2.0.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lambdafish

Its not only a good idea, but it is probably THE most requested DoL feature since 2.0.

---

im still new, have the devs acknowledged it at all since then? is there a specific reason why it is not a feature?

EDIT: yep, now i see. just visited tons of reddit posts suggesting the same thing. apparently there are very few of them and all of them are very popular, or at least they were since they are archived now...

Usual response is no because other classes don't have access to special inventories for their consumables. Doesn't always make the most sense, given the quantities involved, but the general interpretation is that combat classes should get a special inventory for potions, special inventories for foods, crafting mats, materia, etc, etc. They're refusing because they don't want to give a class special treatment.

At this point we just all hope "inventory expansion" or whatever they're planning somewhere in Stormblood helps this issue.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hasrat

snip

---

so far as i can tell, fishing not only takes a lot of inventory space, it takes the most inventory space as a DoL class. crafting does not count because they are DoH classes, which makes sense to take up a lot of inventory and probably why the inventory exists in the first place.

for DoL classes, Miner and Botanist, your inventory space is being used for whatever you collect. however, for the Fisher DoL, you need to dedicate a large part of your inventory for bait/tackle AND whatever resources you collect. Releasing does not help because the fish do not even take up most of your inventory, its the bait/tackle, in which you do need to keep all types just in case you need to mooch a low level fish.

inventory expansion will not solve this issue: remember that we are getting the entire Stormblood expansion. meaning more content, items, and resources for your inventory. plus, different fish = different bait types.

Fore sure. If they want a system with that kind of depth and 50+ kinds of bait it shouldn't negatively affect gameplay so much.

While I love the idea of a tackle box for a secondary tool I think assigning inventory functionality to an existing equip slot is probably the most complex solution to design and code. What happens to the bait when you unequip the tacklebox? Where's that information stored for viewing if you are on a different class? Can you buy bait if you aren't currently a fisher and have it make sense?

Maybe if they just made a completely new and separate equip slot in the Armory slot that was only for bait?

A sloppier but maybe even easier option might be to just re-assign part of the Key Item section of the inventory to bait.

Hope they address this in SB though. I want to get more into fishing but until they either bring their Glamour system up to par with Blizzard's or they give fishing the space it needs it's gonna be a real juggling act.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sated

snip

---

i assume it would be much simpler. just place whatever bait we buy in our inventory as it does now, then allow us to manually place and remove the bait within our tacklebox. if there is bait still within the tacklebox, then the player is not allowed to unequip it. if they do not want to add any immersion, then they could just add another independent inventory slot specifically for bait: no off-hand.

at this point of time, ive sold all of my bait. there is now a lot more room in my inventory and i am able to conveniently have some materials while crafting.

I think their solution to the inventory issue was to just reduce the number of new baits/lures in Heavensward.. I kinda doubt we'll ever get a tackle box.

What about making Lures as its own skill as something you can toggle on and off as needed for the areas but baits will be baits you need stacks off?

Or have exiting lures provide a small Freshwater/Salt Water/Aether buff to help catch HQ fish for using them in tandem with the Lure stance toggle ability?

I am curious if they are going to add even more tackle and bait come 4.0. I wouldn't mind if they reuse old stuff instead.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nightcap

What about making Lures as its own skill as something you can toggle on and off as needed for the areas but baits will be baits you need stacks off?

Or have exiting lures provide a small Freshwater/Salt Water/Aether buff to help catch HQ fish for using them in tandem with the Lure stance toggle ability?

---

In 1.x bait and lures had stats...