Gathering Rate node bonus

Printable View

07-05-2015, 01:36 AM
Issac

Gathering Rate node bonus

I think it's a general oversight. By the time someone has that much gathering stat, the rate is already 100%.

Is that really working as intended? I don't understand.

All the other bonuses make sense.
07-05-2015, 02:22 AM
Airget

Eh there are some things to consider.

Unknown items are always 25% base unless you buff yourself. Gathering Bonus makes these a tad easier to find, with hidden items even if you get bonus you might not have hidden and pretty much "Gathering Bonus" is one of those bonus's more supportive of leveling/keeping a gathering chain and for uncovering unknown items with super ease than it is for end game.
07-05-2015, 03:23 AM
Nekodar

Quote:

Originally Posted by Issac

I think it's a general oversight. By the time someone has that much gathering stat, the rate is already 100%.

Is that really working as intended? I don't understand.

All the other bonuses make sense.

Uhm... Which bonus are you talking about exactly? I have yet to see any not make sense.
07-05-2015, 03:30 AM
Issac

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nekodar

Uhm... Which bonus are you talking about exactly? I have yet to see any not make sense.

[Gathering Rate +10%] Gathering > X
[Gathering Rate +25%] Gathering > X

These both have conditions in which if you meet them, you're already at 100% gathering rate anyway.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Airget

Eh there are some things to consider.

Unknown items are always 25% base unless you buff yourself. Gathering Bonus makes these a tad easier to find, with hidden items even if you get bonus you might not have hidden and pretty much "Gathering Bonus" is one of those bonus's more supportive of leveling/keeping a gathering chain and for uncovering unknown items with super ease than it is for end game.

I suppose you're right about that... But then again, it seems silly to have such a thing for that purpose only. If your goal is uncovering something for the first time, that skill that boosts your gathering rate 50% only costs 250 GP invalidates the need at all. x_X
07-05-2015, 03:32 AM
Kilyne

Don't try to find any sense. If it's not 100% there's always more than 50% chance to fail, even at 99%.
07-05-2015, 03:54 AM
Waliel

My 54 BTN has ~400 gathering and I need around 460 for Dravania Forelands +X% gathering bonus, if i'm remembering right. 80-85% chance for an item my level, I think -- would be nice to get that bonus.
07-05-2015, 04:03 AM
Issac

Quote:

Originally Posted by Waliel

My 54 BTN has ~400 gathering and I need around 460 for Dravania Forelands +X% gathering bonus, if i'm remembering right. 80-85% chance for an item my level, I think -- would be nice to get that bonus.

But by the time you meet that requirement, you don't need the bonus anymore.
07-05-2015, 04:07 AM
Nekodar

I have received that bonus plenty of times when it was needed...
07-05-2015, 04:28 AM
Issac

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nekodar

I have received that bonus plenty of times when it was needed...

I've noticed the pointless bonus in several areas all around 3.0 zones these past few days, been mining a lot.
07-05-2015, 04:33 AM
Nekodar

Quote:

Originally Posted by Issac

I've noticed the pointless bonus in several areas all around 3.0 zones these past few days, been mining a lot.

It could be as simple as random requirement for random bonus.
07-05-2015, 05:09 AM
Issac

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nekodar

It could be as simple as random requirement for random bonus.

The requirement has always been the same though x.X For example, let's say my gathering rate is 84%. The bonus is +25% and requires 60 more gathering than what I have. By the time I have that 60 extra, welp, my gathering rate will be 100%. Does 125% do anything for me? No.
07-05-2015, 05:25 AM
Vandril

The bonuses do make sense. I've had just above the gathering needed for these bonuses at each tier of node in HW, and at that time I was usually ~90% gathering chance, sometimes as low as 85% for the higher level items from the nodes and even 77% for the treasure maps. So, there IS a purpose, it's just...usually the +25% chance bonus is a wee bit overkill.
07-05-2015, 05:42 AM
Nekodar

Quote:

Originally Posted by Issac

The requirement has always been the same though x.X For example, let's say my gathering rate is 84%. The bonus is +25% and requires 60 more gathering than what I have. By the time I have that 60 extra, welp, my gathering rate will be 100%. Does 125% do anything for me? No.

Example: Cloud Mica... Level 58 item... I have level 60 Miner with Gathering 556.
It shows up as 95%.
On some nodes I get a bonus for having gathering over 498. Putting me at 100%.

Does the bonus do anything for me? Certainly!
07-05-2015, 07:44 AM
Issac

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nekodar

Example: Cloud Mica... Level 58 item... I have level 60 Miner with Gathering 556.
It shows up as 95%.
On some nodes I get a bonus for having gathering over 498. Putting me at 100%.

Does the bonus do anything for me? Certainly!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vandril

The bonuses do make sense. I've had just above the gathering needed for these bonuses at each tier of node in HW, and at that time I was usually ~90% gathering chance, sometimes as low as 85% for the higher level items from the nodes and even 77% for the treasure maps. So, there IS a purpose, it's just...usually the +25% chance bonus is a wee bit overkill.

Ah, so I was missing something. I assumed it would be 100% by the time you met the requirements. That's all I was looking for, thanks. :P