SMN book. Relic or Moogle?

I can't seem to decide between the two. Their damage is only slightly difference, but wondering if the Cirt on the Mogbook would eventually make up for the small boost in damage from the relic.

SMN Relic stats: http://xivdb.com/?item/2213/Veil-of-Wiyu

Mogtome: http://xivdb.com/?item/2207/Majestic-Mogtome

The damage difference on ruin was about 5-6hp.

Take the relic +1 or the extreme primal one.

imo
mogtome > relic

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shamirah

Take the relic +1 or the extreme primal one.

---

Not getting the +1 for SMN. (Healers are mains) And I have both the Relic and Moogle, so trying to decide which is better.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JonFarron

Not getting the +1 for SMN. (Healers are mains) And I have both the Relic and Moogle, so trying to decide which is better.

---

Relic.

/10chars

relic. i80 > i75

Omnitome.

/10char

The moogle book is better in my opinion. The more crit chance you can stack the better.

Weapon Damage increase > all

Relic is better then Mog in every way.

If you aren't looking to go past i80 then the Titan book is probably your best bet. Same magic damage, int and vit as relic but also has accuracy. Since if you aren't maining SMN you probably aren't going out of your way to get accuracy on it either

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Azoryl

Weapon Damage increase > all

---

This, a million times this. Weapon Damage > Main stat > Secondary stats

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JetBrooks

This, a million times this. Weapon Damage > Main stat > Secondary stats

---

Does anyone have actual stat weights? I know generalized stat weights are always rally rough but it'd be interesting to have a comparison.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sylari

Does anyone have actual stat weights? I know generalized stat weights are always rally rough but it'd be interesting to have a comparison.

---

I'm not sure about SMN stat weights, but I'd reckon you'd want determination and crit over spell speed. If your gear provides you the luxury of choosing between the two, you're probably at the point that your gear is so good it doesn't matter either way, unless you're going for absolute BiS.

The mog book is better because its super cute.